Story retcon? (probably not) (Patreon)

I got some interesting story feedback that I actually somewhat agree with RE: day 8's fetish flag choices. Essentially on day 8, you choose between SPH or not (enables some extra dialog about ur smol pp in sex scenes) - and if you do - you get a further choice about Vanilla's 'virginity' (if ur pp was too smol to pop her cherry or not)

I was considering some options as I agree some changes here would be good:
1) Retcon story - Vanilla is a virgin from the start of the game. The player was too insecure, too nervous to ever go further than oral/kissing/etc. Vanilla's pent up needs are what pushes the NTR plot forward.
2) Leave as is - just clean up the fetish flag choices a bit but leave the whole plot of Vanilla only having experienced sex with the player and slowly finding out that there's much better alternatives.

I do see some novelty in option 1 and some interesting things to explore, but personally I prefer option 2 and think it's a slightly more realistic corruption route - and I'm not sure about retconning existing story beats. I'm really curious what you guys think as it's the first critical story feedback I've gotten ^^