FF7 Rebirth Spoiler question (Patreon)

So with the tifa model beta release, I was wondering what you guys think of the custom Tifa's "scar" location. In my original model long ago I did added one but it was located vertically, I did th same this time but the more I look at "that scene" the scar looks very horizontal, based on older FF media the scar probably went through her chest upper area but well, Rebirth kinda retconed that didn't?

Which one you think looks better?

Here's the original released version scar

Here's a shot from Rebirth with her visible scar (blood warning) :((((((((((((((((((

Here's the newer version

 I added an extra 7zip containing this scar version textures into the [model folder in the release post] in case you are interested

Let me know what you guys think, which one should be the definitive version?