Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout
haven't archived this post yet. have a subscription? use the importer!

Content

Attempted to make a Helmholtz resonator for the Accord to eliminate the very specific and very annoying rasp on decel. The build itself was successful. I can easily remove this capped pipe to change the length of it. The result was not successful (yet).

See, in order for these resonators to work they have to be a very specific length. There is a calculator online to help with this, but you need to know the operating temperature of the exhaust and hertz of the sound you’re trying to eliminate. I unfortunately know neither of these. I tried to use an audio decoder thing on my phone to record the hertz of the rasp, but it’s very quick and it was hard to pinpoint on the recording.

The plan is to shorten this pipe by 1” and test it. If it doesn’t work, shorten it again. The shorter it is the higher frequency it’s supposed to eliminate.

The goal with this is to remove the rasp but not make the car any quieter. It’s already quite quiet and I really don’t want to make it quieter with a bigger resonator.

I’ll follow up with results tomorrow!

Files

Previews only

Comments

Josh Fackler

Watch this. Maybe it'll help https://youtu.be/BOF04R1SggU?si=waWQX7SjqnXP34GL

Stephen Landon

Could you make a series of “trombone slides” of different lengths?

Curtis Gingue

Curious if you've determined you're already at the limit in length? I'm worried you'll keep iterating smaller only to find it needed to be longer in the first place.

Aron Dierker

This sounds like a fun experiment vid

FireFly Epic

Get an audio recording of the vehicle, and adjust a bandpass filter on your computer until you only hear just the rasp (use something like audacity). Then you know the frequency range that the rasp exists within. Don't worry too much about the temp. Temp only affects the speed of sound a bit; for example, between 300 degrees F and 500 F, the speed of sound is only 6% faster, meaning you'll attenuate frequencies 6% higher than you want (so it shouldnt be an issue if you can guess the temp within +-100F, for example)