Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout
haven't archived this post yet. have a subscription? use the importer!

Downloads

  • Super Supportive 205.epub

Missing 1 file.

Content

Scheduling Reminder: I plan to have the next chapter to you on the 31st!

******

Alden poured what was left of his cup of dried fish mix into a plastic bag that had held one of his disposable ponchos. He couldn’t find anything that looked like a waste receptacle here, and the Artonan boy he’d questioned had already escaped into the library proper. 

After belatedly worrying about the safety of his breakfast, Alden had asked the System about it and been informed, via a message that had an unnecessarily amused tone to it, that yovkews were bad for his liver. He wasn’t going to get sick from having a few, but scarfing them like potato chips would mean he needed to take a potion. 

They were more okay than delicious, and he liked all of his organs. So why risk it? He didn’t think eating another and trying to interpret the gremlin’s complete lack of interest one more time was going to result in a breakthrough. He could look into something like this and wonder about it when he got back home.

This weekend is too much.

Yesterday, Natalie wanted to date me. This morning I met a bokabv. I’m a few steps away from finding out what the “top library” at the Rapport I school looks like, and I’ve eaten a handful of toxic meat that the gremlin somehow knows is fine and dandy as far as triggering its sacred rites goes.

Any one of those would have been enough to fill his thoughts and occupy him for the rest of the day. If all the shocks, puzzles, and must-dos could just patiently wait for their own turn, that would be great.

On top of that, Stuart had been saying some things before Noh-en’s arrival had interrupted him that Alden was going to need to approach with a clear head.

What if there really is a path for me that’s just easier than everything I’m scared of? One where shitty summons don’t happen. One where I never run out of refusals because I get mostly normal jobs. 

A path where keeping my head down and being a quiet Rabbit, doing a better job of it than I have been…works.

It felt like a distant possibility without Stuart standing in front of him saying some version of, “Literally, you dumb human, you’re going to have to beg summoners to let you do anything more dangerous than wielding a butter knife from now on.”

What he said made sense. It just doesn’t feel real to me.

He wondered if he should ask Yenu-pezth to spend some time during his upcoming inward path session focusing on his inability to shake the gnawing sense of doom that had only gotten worse after the Submerger crisis.

He blinked down at his bag of dehydrated fish. “One thing at a time,” he told himself.

He was in a wizard library, unmonitored. How often could he anticipate something like this happening? 

He needed to make it count.

Moments later, he was stepping through the doorway into the main room. Not what I was expecting, he thought. 

When Quinyeth had said she was bringing him here so that he’d have something interesting to do while he waited on Stuart, Alden had been hoping for a moment alone in a place full of books. If he’d had a wish list for the experience, then learning a little bit about contract magic so that he could make good on his promise to Boe would have been at the top of it. But the library didn’t have any immediately visible books in it at all. 

This was one of those places that would never be mistaken for its Earth counterparts beyond the first glance. Rows of shelves curved around the room, and in the center, there were some simple wooden tables and chairs. After that, the differences were more apparent than the similarities.

The shelves were covered in collections of cubes, spheres, and pyramids made out of different materials. Mostly stone.

Alden actually had an educated guess about what they were based on what Kibby had told him big kids got to use at their big kid schools. You did something to activate them, and they gave you a multi-sensory experience of whatever had been recorded on them.

Neat. For the people who knew how to use them.

Maybe there are books farther in. Or anything I can understand would be fine.

He’d known that reading on tablets and through eye pieces was ubiquitous on the Triplanets, but surely some of the students here liked a book every now and then. The Primary did. Stuart’s house had a whole library floor specifically called the manuscript library. 

Why couldn’t he have sparked a fad with the youth? Used his power for bringing printed tomes back in style.

Alden walked quickly between the shelves, hungry for knowledge that was locked away inside carved shapes he dared not touch. Breaking one of them would probably shame him, Alis-art’h, and Stuart. They were tempting, though. Especially when he noticed there were seats built into the shelving units. 

They were little cubbies for one, with compartments in front of the seated person that were perfectly sized to fit the different recorder shapes. He wondered if the setup might be for people who didn’t want to run the recorders with whatever spell or technique you were supposed to use to activate them. They definitely had a population at the school who would appreciate something like that. Stuart had said even adults came here for classes sometimes, which meant the knights, which meant people who weren’t in the mood to cast. 

Focus on finding something that you’re reasonably sure is safe, Alden told himself. You don’t need brain damage to go with the liver damage, and who knows if these thing are human-friendly?

Not long after that, he heard voices coming from the direction of the door. At least three people, he thought. 

No. Not yet. He sped up. It’s the weekend. Go sleep in some more. I haven’t found anything good yet.

He’d seen the number of first meal offerings in the entry room, waiting for takers. They wouldn’t be there if the library didn’t regularly receive visitors even on the students’ days off.

When he reached the last row of shelves, only more recorders greeted him, and beyond those shelves, he encountered the wall. The boy who’d confirmed for him that he was eating meat earlier was nearby in a window seat. He had a cube in one hand and a tablet in the other. One eye was closed. With that much going on in his head at once, the guy probably wouldn’t notice Alden unless Alden walked right up beside him and poked him. 

He kept his distance anyway, and he stayed quiet. Just in case the boy’s alarm at finding an unattended alien eating the snacks had settled down enough for him to insist on answers instead of rushing off like he’d seen an unclimbing beast. 

Should I put on the pezyva to flash the commendation? Alden wondered. Yet another situation Tuck and Yinuo didn’t cover. When roaming a library in search of a quick wizarding education, which version of my outfit is less suspicious?

He pulled the pezyva out of his messenger bag and put it on. A few steps later, he caught a glimpse of himself in the reflective surfaces of a few metal shields that hung on the wall. 

Well, now I definitely can’t risk anything too embarrassing.

He glanced up toward the balcony level that circled the room. That partial second floor might hold something different than the shelves down here did. He could see that there were cabinets up there. And he might have some more privacy to browse if he kept away from the railing. 

The voices of the students who’d arrived a short while ago were still chattering away. Maybe the library didn’t come with an expectation of quiet.

He made his way around the edge of the room to one of the ladders that provided access. It was built of woven roots that weren’t connected to anything alive, as far as he could tell. 

While climbing, he would be visible from almost the whole lower floor. If anyone looked up…

The worst that can happen is someone asking me what I’m doing. It won’t be some sign to everyone here that I have an authority sense and need to be taken into custody to avoid confusing the entire known universe.

He still took a few seconds to invent an excuse he could give as soon as he was questioned about his purpose. He’d say that he was going upstairs to admire this awesome learning space from a different angle. That would have been strange-sounding reason if he was at Celena North, but he thought it worked here. 

His hand fell on a ladder rung and the feel of rough, knobby root under his palm gave him one more reason to hesitate.

[Climbing this isn’t offensive to the tree that made it, right? It’s not going to be insulted that a human hauled his heavy human body up?] he asked through a text to no one.

He waited for the reply, sure it was taking longer than usual.

[Your questions are so delightful this morning. No tree will be insulted.]

[You could just tell me what’s in the cabinets and if it’s useful to me,] he suggested.

[Can you imagine how surprised everyone would be to learn that I had given you the books you already have?] she countered.

Surprised is probably too mild a word for it. He hoped Alis-art’h didn’t come back home and discover that her entire account of stored up favors had been bankrupted by the Artona I kernel taking her request to help Alden not die and running with it in directions she couldn’t possibly have imagined.

[Thank you again for those. I’ll figure out the cabinets on my own.]

It was a short climb, and he made it swiftly. But before he was at the top, the voices stopped. His stomach clenched in anticipation of someone calling out to him in curiosity or alarm, but he pulled himself up onto the upper level smoothly. Then, he made himself turn with a smile to address whoever was about to comment on his presence. Only to discover that he hadn’t been spotted after all.

From up here, the group that had entered the library a couple of minutes ago was easy to spot. There were three of them, and they’d gone quiet because they were using one of the stones together. They were all sitting around it, on the floor beside the shelf it must have been taken from. Two of them had both eyes closed, and one was busy drawing something on her tablet.

Lucky, he thought, moving away from the balcony railing so that he wouldn’t be on display. 

All right. What have we got up here? 

Cabinets about the same height as him were arranged so that they formed the walls of short, narrow aisles. Woven rugs on the floor between them were decorated with poems about the duty and pleasure of acquiring knowledge. The railing stood at one end of the cabinet corridors, and at the other, floor cushions were evenly spaced against a wall covered in huge paintings that Alden saw as blurs of uninterpretable color.

He was familiar with that type of magic from Artonan artwork he’d encountered at the same museum where he’d had the realistic volcanic eruption experience. They were paintings you wouldn’t be able to see unless you were positioned correctly. It was supposed to increase their impact if you only viewed them from the ideal angle.

Right now, he was more interested in the contents of the cabinets. Each of them had between one and four identifying labels on it, in the form of carved tags of paler wood that were stuck to the fronts of the sliding doors. Unfortunately, they weren’t intended to be helpful to a human looking for information. They had names on them.

Instructor Cabro-neethe, Instructor Mesuvi-athet, Instructor Yond-waro…

He walked around the entire balcony searching for a tag that would tell him more, but there were only two cabinets that weren’t labeled with specific instructors. Instead, they both said, “Exceptional pursuits.”

Alden stood by one of those, trying to think of what the worst outcome of opening it could be. This is a library for students. The cabinet’s not going to explode in my face. 

He was ninety percent confident that she would have at least hinted at lethal threats up here when he’d asked her about the ladder. So probably it’s nothing more dangerous than the trail mix anyway.

He took his stylus from his bag, stood as far back as he could, and gently pushed the door with it. He intended to open it just a crack to start with, but it glided aside smoothly, as if he’d given it a firm push.

In the moment when it slid back faster than he’d expected, he thought of multiple reasons why he shouldn’t have opened it that were better than an explosion but still bad. What if there was an alarm? What if the cabinet was full of something extremely light sensitive that would be damaged if he didn’t cast a protective spell first?

He let out a breath as the contents were revealed. Books!

Six shelves full of them. He stepped closer, sticking the stylus back into his bag as he examined the spines. They were different colors, many of them bright shades. Their heights were all the same, and the range of widths seemed off for them to be a random assortment. They were almost all slim, and instead of names or titles, the spines were covered in an eclectic mix of embellishments. From single lines drawn down the center, to tiny gemstones, to flowers and scrollwork. The effect was a bunch of books that looked like they weren’t sure if they wanted to be part of a set or not. 

The reason for that was revealed when Alden took a salmon pink one with nine horizontal stripes on the spine from the shelf and saw the information pressed into the front of the cover. A student name, an instructor name, and a range of dates from two Artonan years ago were followed by the description, “Thoughts on Stretching Multiple Hides Using a Chant of Expansion.”

They must be student journals. Or long essays.

After picking up a few and carefully flipping through pages, he knew it was closer to the former. Each one was a record of the student’s attempts to engage independently with the subject the instructor was teaching, and to Alden, it seemed that they were written with the expectation that other students in the same class would read them.

There were some things that sounded like they might be jokes. And there were lots of compliments and mentions of gratitude toward classmates who had offered the journalers insight into the subject they were exploring.

The more Alden read, the more he began to build a picture of what school might be like for the upperclassmen here. 

Ending your study journal abruptly, without any major revelations or answers to the questions that had prompted you to start it, seemed to be fine. The closing could include the author expressing relief that they’d solved a problem that had been bothering them, or it could be them frankly telling the reader that they were getting bored with it and stopping for now. That combined with the fact that these were in the case labeled exceptional pursuits, made him think that the point of the journals was to pursue a personal curiosity beyond the scope of what the students had to know to satisfy instructor requirements.

Classmates interacted with most of the journals by adding notes at the end that thanked the writer, pointed to relevant reference materials, or mentioned that they’d started studies of their own on a similar subject.

And being quoted in someone else’s journal was a thing at least some of them took seriously. There were multiple instances of journalers asking someone for their thoughts and then not getting a reply back for days because the other person was crafting a paragraph that was almost always deemed astoundingly insightful when it was finally included. 

It might just be that anyone making one of these only asks the biggest geeks in the school for advice.

The journals weren’t what Alden had hoped for as far as educating himself went. But what he’d hoped for was a great big book called Tattooing Yourself with Friends Who Are Sometimes Cats: A Guide, and that wasn’t the most reasonable thing to want.

These are actually so neat, he thought, admiring the journals. 

But they stung him, too. A little. More than a little. Because even though these were written by young people, he was years behind them. 

Decades, Alden. Admit to yourself that it’s decades…and that’s assuming you keep getting your hands on new books.

The authors didn’t seem that far away from him and the teenagers he knew in many ways. The person with the pink and black journal had a good sense of humor. The bright red one with the yellow vine on the spine was super social with their learning; he or she liked to involve as many members of the class in the project as possible. Someone who wrote in a dark gray one drew a diagram, illustration, or chart on every other page with elegant flourishes.

Alden could follow the journeys their thoughts took from curiosity to comprehension. But while he got a sense of their personalities and could see that their knowledge was growing, the specifics of that knowledge…the questions they were asking and the answers they were arriving at and the magic they were describing—he couldn’t figure it out.

These are the pursuits that someone thought were exceptional. Maybe if I read whatever is in the other cabinets I’d have more of a chance.

He slid the red one back into its place. Probably that’s the last time I’ll ever touch this, he thought as his fingers withdrew. 

Because he couldn’t imagine ending up in this library on his own again without making some leaps, and no matter how many leaps he made, he couldn’t imagine ending up here with time to appreciate the writings of one student in one class on reversible transmogrification. 

Reading these whenever you want is something you have time for if you’re one of those wizards down there. He thought of the students on the floor below him. Not me.

He told himself it was one of those things he was going to be okay with because he had to be okay with it. 

It worked well enough for now.

He moved through the journals more pragmatically after that, just glancing at the subject on them to get an idea about whether they could be useful to him even if quickly skimmed and poorly understood. Viewed through that lens, none of them were. The students in these classes were dealing with magical questions that were way out of his league.

I should have asked to see a lower library. This will teach me not to try to graduate from kindergarten ahead of schedule.

He was halfway down the second shelf, reaching for a green book, when the one that was four down from it suddenly caught his eye. It was an average thickness, and it hadn’t stood out until now because it was sandwiched between others that were also in pastel shades. 

A purple so soft it was almost white, with a silver swoop near the top.

That’s Stuart’s auriad color. That’s it exactly.

He skipped the others to take it and found that he was right. The pale purple journal was from last year. Stu-art’h’s name was stamped on it above a silver line that squiggled a couple of times before disappearing over the edge. Inside one of the silver curves was a small shape Alden recognized. The round shape—a not-quite-spherical blob maybe—with pointy rays protruding from it.

It’s the symbol he embroiders on some of his belts.

According to the cover, this was Stuart’s study of, “Mysteries from the History of Teleportation and How to Approach Researching Them Without Resorting to Unethical Methods.” Cool. So he was already thinking hard about magical transportation when he wrote this.

Alden wondered if this study was sparked because of his budding interest in Maker of Narrow Ways or if it was the other way around. He opened it and started reading from the first page because he was sure Stuart would be offended if he skipped to the middle. 

The flash card translation had been working overtime since Alden had made it up here. These students had some writing quirks he didn’t recognize, and they were super fond of the various creative toning tricks. While Alden would have liked the word-gamey quality it gave the reading experience at another time, right now trying to figure out why a journaler wanted him to experience the logogram for “hominess” simultaneously with a thought they’d had about laying animal skins out in sets of two would make him crazy. 

By contrast, Stuart’s opening page was refreshingly straightforward.

“Teleportation was a treasure found too early,” he wrote. “The wizards of that earliest era hadn’t learned to appreciate our own Mother world. They hadn’t learned to desire the unity of our own species. If legends have truth in them, then the first Artonan to leave our planet did so because he was trying to reach a mountaintop. The only thing more shocking than the strength of his authority must have been his inability to judge what the effects of using it would be.”

Alden fought back a laugh. So Stuart’s not too impressed with the first teleporter.

“Obviously this isn’t an uncommon opinion among wizards trained as we are today. I doubt anyone will ever solve the mystery of whether or not that first legend is true, but since we are still trying to learn what happened during teleportation accidents that are documented better, I intend to study the ethical questions that arise from that research. I would like to form thoughtful opinions about this subject and share them with all of you so that we can hone one another’s understanding.

“I’ll begin by looking for information about the practice of collecting blood from the descendants of those suspected of dimension piercing… ”

After that, he made a reading list, then blazed through it with lots of commentary Alden couldn’t understand without having access to the references. What did come through were Stuart’s earnest attempts to grapple with whatever the moral conundrums were.

It’s a very Stuart journal. Alden smiled. I like it.

Before he continued reading, he did skip to the very end. Not to find out how the studying of the subject had ended but to see if Stuart’s classmates had added material. He imagined that having lots of comments and shared information from the others was exciting for the person who wrote the journal.

At the back, he found the added pages he’d been hoping to see. Several students had interacted with Stuart’s work. Alden was pleased for him until he gradually noticed what felt like an off note running through their contributions. 

Normally, he would have dismissed something so mild because aliens and translations. But this was being translated for him by the System that had done his last affixation and then nudged him over to the Primary’s house to say hello.

If Artonan was ever going to be spoon-fed to him with maximum accuracy it was here, by her, while he was trying to glean social information about Stu-art’h.

Noh-en read it. 

Alden studied her addition. It was a suggestion that Stuart might want to contact a certain historian and request a season of mentorship. “Your curiosity about this topic could blossom into a flower worth a far walk, if you give it a little more time.”

It was a nice thing to say, and if this had been the only journal Alden had picked up, it wouldn’t have seemed out of place at all. But he had looked in the backs of several others. And in those, he’d only seen one or two comments that could be taken as advice to the author. They were usually more cooperative, just adding information that would help everyone who might read the journal. Or they were pure gratitude. 

Alden didn’t think there were supposed to be expectations of future study placed on the writer, but Noh-en’s wasn’t the only suggestion that Stuart pursue this subject further. And one person mentioned that he might want to go into summonarium construction.

Yeah, they’re being pushy with him. Like they can urge him into liking this topic in a way that slows him down or doesn’t fit with his plans for himself at all.

He became surer of it the more he read the comments, and he was soon hoping that the Stuart of the past had missed the subtext and enjoyed the compliments from his friends. Maybe someone had given him the kinds of conversation he wanted face to face without inserting subtle roadblocks.

On the very last page, Stuart referred the curious reader to another study he’d pursued, along with the name of the instructor whose class had influenced it. Alden shut the door and carried the journal with him until he found that instructor’s cabinet. When he opened it, the pale purple journal in the middle stood out.

So they do keep journals from recent graduates up here, too. 

He took it and turned to the last page. By following the breadcrumb trail of references Stuart had left, Alden managed to collect seven of his journals over the next few minutes. When he had them all, he knelt on a cushion as far out of sight from the library below as he could get and studied the dates, titles, and any comments from classmates.

Even with these few, there was a clear pattern. The two that seemed to have been written before Stuart announced that he’d made his choice had classmate interactions more like that ones Alden had seen in the others he’d read. Then came the ethics of solving teleportation mysteries. From that point on, it had changed. 

Stuart had written one on “Learning about Methods for Drawing Similar Life Together,” which was basically an admission that he wanted to send a bean to another bean as far as Alden could tell, but by then, he didn’t seem to be confiding the specifics of which skills he was considering to the rest of them. They’d left notes for him in that one with the same kind of, “Please take a few years studying this more,” undercurrents that the ethics one had had. Alden didn’t think they would have done that if they’d realized this was a skill-specific interest, because the one journal that was absolutely, undeniably a study written by a future knight trying to figure out what skill he might like was completely devoid of comments. Like they’d all refused to read it, or refused to acknowledge that they had. 

Perhaps that was their only recourse. Alden hadn’t seen any criticisms in the journals. Maybe if you didn’t have anything nice to say, you just didn’t say anything at all. 

The subject of Stuart’s study for that one was “Skills Rooted in Concepts of Connection.” 

It was the thickest of his journals. The single blank page at the back, waiting for a comment, was crushing Alden’s soul. He had two warring impulses as he stared at it. The first was to grab a pen and write the most glowing praise for Stuart’s skill choice he could think of. The second was to take the journal away from the library because the adolescent wizard twits who shunned it didn’t deserve to have access to it anymore. 

Before he could talk himself out of either course, a loud voice from below said, “You saw a human in here?”

And Alden’s thoughts raced straight toward a fact that suddenly seemed very obvious—he was holding seven journals filled with information that he wouldn’t have been invited to access by wizards who’d been trained in proper discretion. 

He’d gotten so invested because these were Stuart’s. But seven was a lot. Seven was too many to put back on the right shelves before someone who was interested in looking for him found him, and seven journals by the same author was less, “Just poking around,” and more, “I’m intentionally collecting these for some purpose.”

What if Stuart’s mad that I looked at them? What if I get him in trouble? Whoever’s downstairs could be up here in a second. Do something! 

He shoved six of them into his bag and one into a pocket hidden in his pezyva and scrambled as quietly as possible off of the cushion toward the nearest painting, thinking that being found staring at it was the most innocent thing he could possibly be doing up here. As he rose from a squat, nerves making his pulse race, his eyes crossed the appropriate point to let him experience the piece as the artist had intended. 

And he discovered that the artist had intended to take the viewer into chaos.


******
Previous Chapter

Next Chapter

Comments

Sashani

Yay!

Partha Peddi

It is here :) tyftc

Anthony Lutz

Thank you, now go rest Typo: cabinets about his height as him... Looks like you changed your mind about it mid sentence

Thomas Todd

It's such a brutal experience reading about how Stu was treated because on one hand I want to scream at all the people who are trying to block his path but on the other I understand them, they care about him and want the best for him but it's also so condescending that they believe he doesn't have the right to make his own choice. I want to be angry for Stu but it ends up just making me sad that the best intentions of his friends and family falls so short of the support he deserves

Sky23

The single blank page at the back, waiting for a comment, was crushing Alden’s soul. He had two warring impulses as he stared at it. The first was to grab a pen and write the most glowing praise for Stuart’s skill choice he could think of. The second was to take the journal away from the library because the adolescent wizard twits who shunned it didn’t deserve to have access to it anymore. If that ain’t the cutest, gayest thing I’ve ever read! My heart is literally going to explode! Thank you for the delightful chapter as always, and for this line in particular. I am overflowing with queer joy right now!

세희

I love Alden reading Stuart's studies. Including all the emotions crossing them. Thanks for soup!

Taitenator

Oh Alden, you really just can’t catch a break huh? Stu is about to find Alden having Vietnam Flashbacks in the corner of the library. Also the Mother interactions were excellent this chapter, still love every scrap of content we get with her.

Eva

No Alden, don't! Don't put the books in your bag! You could have put them in a pile in a quiet corner and pretended to have nothing to do with them! I feel future embarrassment for you, Alden.

Stargazer_hfy

Thank you Sleyca. I was in the hospital recently without internet access and catching up on your story was one of the things I most looked forward to while I was waiting to get out.

MatrixM

Damn, that was a good chapter and not where I thought the library trip was headed..

Gregory

Alden went into the library hoping to learn more about Artonans, information he couldn’t possibly get on Earth. And he did learn, about one specific Artonan (and his classmates).

Terrestrial_Biped

He was getting interested in teleportation accidents, and then this one Avowed he met died of a "teleportation accident". That must have been... something, to him. I do very much want Alden to leave a glowing comment in that last book.

Gaffer

[Your comments are so delightful this morning, everyone]

Serek

I don't see anything gay or queer about this paragraph at all. Just as there is nothing "straight" about it either. It's about friendship. I completely agree that it's a delightful chapter though.

jg

Couldn't sleep too hot 🔥 looked here Yay!

Swinter

Geesh. Well, good thing Alden is still as young as he is because man is this chapter filled up with poorly thought out decisions xD. At least he shows he can be as immature as the rest of the people his age. Even if it's about potential magic books instead of girls.

Sesharan

I feel like one of the things that Alden is learning here, in relation to his Choosing Season, is that Stuart having a friend who’s interested in and impressed by his wizardry as he chooses to pursue it would be a good thing for Stuart, not just for Alden.

J Reynolds

So we have the comparison direct here, right in the title. The chapter is in the Herdcreatures section. And we're seeing Stu's classmates acting in unison - like herdcreatures. Maybe ALL people who want to become hn'ytons get this pushback. Neha mentioned that seeing generals was like seeing an endangered animal in the wild. So maybe one wizard in a hundred thousand become knights? In which case, it would make sense that Stu is encountering resistance.

J Reynolds

EDITED TO REFLECT EMMA MASS'S INFO Running some numbers: * 35Bn Artonans * 7Bn Artonans are wizards (20% of total) * 70k knights (one in a hundred thousand wizards) Which would make Evul-art'h very much in the 'among the more powerful knights'. Of course, if it's one in a million wizards become knights, it's 7k knights. And Evul is still in the top 50%. The last number is just a guess. However, I wouldn't be surprised if the number of knights was between 7k and 70k. Thanks to Emma for the corrections. My memory isn't what it used to be, I guess.

TheShadowMuffin

Normally i don't like the comments suggesting Alden might reveal is wizard powers (by accident or nor). But this one of the few chapters that could actually lay the foundations for that. Not any time soon. I see Alden as the one to truly accept and drive Stu'arth forward in his path of a knight. He will become his safe harbor to weather the storms to come and in time join him on the journey ahead. But for now he will be the one to affirm Stu'arth. The one to push him forward. The one that truly supports him. He will be Stu'arth super supporter.

Emma Mass

It said that wizards actually make up 20% of the population so it should be 6 billion. But the last estimated I saw for total artonon population size was approximately 35 billion so 7 billion then? The highest number we've seen so far is Evul art being in the 2000s I expect hn'tyons are even smaller group than 90k. Probably less than 50k

Emma Mass

Honestly I wouldn't blame Alden. I'm young too but I don't think being older would've made me make any better decisions. I imagine I would have made worse choices that Alden and touched pretty much everything I came into contact with or tried to figure out how to use those immersion learning material

Robert Mullins

Alden finally taking some lessons from crime lord Kivb-ee.

Unknown

I can't wait for the next chapter! Good job!

Nathan

Thanks Sleyca!

JennP

They're trying to use peer pressure and maybe even a kind of friendship blackmail to force him to do what they think he should. This won't be good for him when he's trying to deal with post-afixation strain. Especially when added to his family's manipulation. Poor Stu, no one trusts him. Except Alden

JennP

Right? Will he confess and give them to Stu? Will he take them home with him? Then what? I can imagine his future stress.

Robert Mullins

Impressed by it without the baggage of "Very good, now why don't you focus on this from now on since the subject is so interesting."

Kitsune

I'll admit despite liking the plot and direction and understand the threads and where they are going, I'm getting a bit tired of "quiet rabbit" spiral and Alden thinking like he is gonna be executed. Again, I get it but its wearing down on me. In general, in his current mindset I'm finding that I don't actually like Alden all that much, as a character, when he is alone in the story. Once more, I understand they way it is going and the why's and that there will be pay off from this build up, nor has my overall enjoyment dimished but yeah I'm just not vibing with all of Alden when he is solo focused.

Chas Becht

Edit suggestion: "How often could he anticipate something this happening? " Should probably read "something **like** this happening"

Jake Lewis

Is Alden going to talk to the therapist about his crushing paranoia?

Unknown

I got the inpression that it was less "executed" and more assassinated. The mother said something like half of artonans will approve of him being a knight and the other half will be mortally terrified and... angry? I'm going to have to go back and reread that again shortly.

Sky23

To each their own interpretation. I related it to things I’ve seen in queer romance novels, as well as my own queer experience. Not forcing anyone to see it the way I do, I just was excited.

Clint

The crazy thing is that I still think Alden’s paranoia is accurate. Avowed are lost on missions all the time, and the known aspects of his skill are incredibly useful in incredibly dangerous circumstances. Then again, Stu should know better than we do about how Artonans use Avowed.

WannaBeATree

Would be kinda in poor taste without having read it, from a library/knowledge perspective. Comments for comments sake, like "first". Though in terms of interpersonal relashionships, it would be nice. :)

WannaBeATree

Again a nice touch with the background. Alden being interested in learning and not getting involved/dodging chaos. As soon as he gets involved with Stu, boom!, chaos. Stashing those books in his bag was . . . well . . . I guess an opportunity to talk with Stu about them? Give an honest comment and have Stu return them later and pretend he took them out? Him cleaning after himself was cute. I wonder what Mother thinks of the coincident of Alden finding those books?

Clint

“This weekend is too much.” I laughed out loud at this. It’s a great reminder of how slowly time is progressing in this story, and consequently how much is happening to Alden in such a short time.

BatheticBoy

Loving these chapters

Jeff Wells

It's a weird thing right? Avowed are lost all the time, but Rabbits aren't. However, Alden knows that he is a very atypical Rabbit, which Stuart only knows a tiny sliver of. So while almost any other Rabbit could reasonably expect to never again be put in another such dangerous situation as Thegund in their lives, Alden really can't. Alden's situation is unique, and it's entirely reasonable to think he will end up called upon for far more dangerous situations than the average Avowed would be, and especially a Rabbit.

Jeff Wells

Even think it all the way through, how could you not? The opportunity is just too huge, you'd regret it for the rest on your life.

Justin

Thanks for the chapter

VP

He so needs to write a response essay to give you Stu

TaborlintheGreat

He is more afraid of being exiled from Earth and having forced into the position of a knight/fighting against chaos. He literally talked about it in Herdcreatures 1

richard p

Alden wizard rabbit and future master of teleportation?

DAK

Not a new thought here, but this chapter continues to drive home how absurdly different choosing seasons are on Earth vs Artona. There is so much thought and culture and time and angst poured into skill choice (and choice to choose a skill choice) compared to a 90 day timer with no reliable history, no understanding of magic and no cultural context whatsoever. It’s interesting to me that more wizards aren’t utterly horrified by the avowed affixation process. And, also, the more I read of Stuart’s choosing drama, the more it seems like Anesidora’s culture is truer to Artona’s than the rest of Earth. The tight buddy system in schools based on hoped for ranks, the stress around choosing and the unraveling friendships when magic and expectations diverge.

PatienceHoney

I can see how, what I am interpreting as, protectiveness and understanding could be a central theme in queer romance. Holding someone and seeing down to their vulnerable core seems like it would strike a chord in the queer community.

Jack

Suuuper good chapter aaa

PatienceHoney

@Swinter I think his curiosity was fine and I only saw one mistake in him trying to hide a natural curiosity. @Emma Mass My comment above may reflect the difference in who I was when I was younger. I still make some of the same mistakes, but now I own them as part of being human.

MatrixM

He's only been in school for six weeks or something. It's kinda insane.

MatrixM

Jo warned against being summoned in the path of a bullet, and that was if he grew his powers without being a knight. Who knows if some would react even worse to a human hn'tyon

Robert Mullins

I suspect she was rubbing her hands together in anticipation of him seeing either the painting or Stu's books. Maybe both.

Catherine

Out of the frying pan into the fire

MatrixM

Also, anyone else struck by Aldens reading speed? Going through even one book would've taken me quite a while, especially with translations. Perhaps a hour idk. Alden went through a bunch, skimmed some, tracked down others...

Sebastian Winter

Alden’s comment about them discovering his authority sense confusing the known universe is interesting. I recently reread the story, and saw several hints that it is not highly unusual for avowed to get an authority sense - it is only said that no other humans have - one major hint is where Joe says he could train Alden to do magic, but would not do so (he says something along the lines of Alden having the right fundamentals to learn).

JustCD

He did put some of his authority into boosting his processing stat if I remember correctly.

Emma Mass

It is actually, highly unusual that avowed gain authority sense. It is just not unheard of. It's very uncommon among any avowed species and entirely novel in humans

Andrew Reise

Well that got serious quickly…I’m assuming when Sleyca said “chaos” they meant the magic, system breaking variety, not just like a hectic, messy painting? I wonder if Artonans have trigger warnings and Alden just missed it in his ignorance

Emma Mass

Avowed being lost in missions is actually atypical and it's why it's such a big deal when it happens. It's not a normal occurrence. By and large, missions rarely cause loss in life or missing status. Both Hannah and Alden are edge cases

Kbzzy

It might just be a depiction of chaos and demons that catches alden off guard and triggers some mild PTSD, not necessarily an authority reaction. The latter would be cooler though

JTP

"First- Hyn'ton Alden" would be a pretty hilarious message to be discovered in 20 years.

SnuggleCat

Yay, soup!

Francis

It is so human to not trust others to make their own decisions. I catch myself doing it so many times, but it hurts so much when you are on the receiving side

Francis

That empty page gave me the feels. I just want Alden to give Stu his journals and tell him that he is not alone and isn't imagining the lack of support from his peers. I'm projecting a lot now, but damn, few things hurt as much as those subtle showings of manipulation that you can't directly confront, because the perpetrators would never understand that what they are doing is hurtful. It is easier to gaslight yourself and think that you imagined it or that they didn't intend it the way they did

Kim Enteiu

Hn’tyon Human Rabbit commended by the 4th General who is Weaving Friendship with a Declared Hn’tyon who is also the Youngest Son of the Primary. I feel like he’s a little more bulletproof than Joe first assumed.

Aspiring Moth

not enough for it to matter. he only has 1.25 points in top level processing. there are many baseline humans smarter than him

Kim Enteiu

Some Artonan “What’s a human doing here?!” Alden, turning to make sure his commendation is in full view “The human is making << a righteous scholarly exit >>.” Alas, instead he walks face-first into the chaos trap. It already reminds me of how the paintings of the eye were described in a journey of black and red.

Kim Enteiu

I love how the title of the chapters alluded to us finding out even more how groups of Artonans can be panicy animals just like humans.

denatured

Sleyca wrote a comment somewhere about not having totally settled on the numbers. I don't recall exactly what she said but I think it was in the tens of thousands, and since it's not confirmed in the story it could change. But Evul is supposed to be powerful.

denatured

He should write a bunch of comments and leave them in a stack in the cottage when he goes. He may have stepped way out of bounds but it seems like Stu likes rule-breakers.

Super Super Supportive Supporter

The painting is a security measure, anyone who doesn’t have strong authority shouldn’t be in this library section and will be swiftly annihilated by the chaos The janitor doesn’t really like it but no one listens to his complaints

OldFishBoi

Thanks for the chapter. I really enjoyed this one. It caused much fruitful blossoming of ideas in the garden of my mind. I look forward to the weeding and the casting of the compostables into the unofficial fan discord.

Alibhai

Of course! It's the most logical detergent. Overkill? There is no such thing!

Sebastian Winter

Definitely highly uncommon, but not so unusual that after a few days of observation Joe could say that he thought Alden could learn magic. That likely, or maybe possibly, means Artonans know how to turn avowed into wizards, but don’t for ethical reasons. A corollary being that Alden revealing his authority sense is more likely to be exciting, and saddening, to the Artonans, rather than shocking. I am hoping that Alden realises this through his conversations with Stu, and overcomes the related fears through his therapy, and then shares that he is a wizard. Personally I am hoping this all happens in the next several or dozen chapters. It would be good for the story to get past the first of his three big reveals (the others obviously being his potential to be a knight, and inheritance from Gorgon).

MatrixM

Iirc 1 point is a 10%buff? Idk how much faster that lets you read, probably is significant but m he read really fast here

Curtis

Can you point to some specific quotes that make you think Joe thought Alden could learn magic? And that Artonans know how to turn avowed into wizards? What chapters/conversations makes you think that?

James Townsend

I'm betting it's like Doctor Who with a slice of time in a painting. Except maybe not necessarily a time but a very accurate depiction of chaos that lets the viewer experience it with more than just sight. And it either lets Alden have a perfect excuse for being frozen there, PTSD etc, or he flies off the handle a little feeling it and reveals some stuff.

JJ Hunter

Alden should take several days composing a perfect paragraph to add to Stu's “Skills Rooted in Concepts of Connection" book and then return that book + the others to Stu to decide whether he wants to return them to the first school library or keep them elsewhere. I am so mad at Stu's former classmates on his behalf - that sense of *shunning* Stu's maturing explorations because they disapproved that strongly is such a resounding rejection of the care he's put into his self-concept and his chosen path. They won't even acknowledge his work; they won't treat him like they treat each other if he won't change to suit them. No wonder Noh-en's exhortation to Stu to tell her if he can't "pretend proper enthusiasm for your current position" hit such an aching sore spot. For better or worse, Stu has committed himself to living without illusions, living aligned with reality and with truth to the best of his capability. He had to grow so much and try so hard to learn the unified language and catch up on all the early experiences he initially missed out on so he could join his peers at school, and he did it! Only to find many of his peers cherish their own illusion of Stu as better suited to being a votary more than the reality of Stu declaring the hn'tyon path and having the capability to follow it successfully.

50cant12

I imagine the rabbit wizard costume would be a reference to a historical example of this gone wrong

Terrestrial_Biped

I mean, he hasn't read the book, but he has heard from Stuart's own lips what he chose and why. He probably has some insights about Stu's skill choice that even the book would not provide. It would certainly be better if he read the book in full, but Alden would never write something as empty as "first", and he has enough background to say something that will be meaningful to Stu.

Emma Mass

Firstly, Joe said that he could teach Alden magic, and that it would take an inconveniently long amount of time for the both of them, not that Alden had the potential to learn magic. What made Alden distinct to Joe was the quality of his authority. That which stuart noticed and got his father to inspect as well. Alden being a "prodigy" in the sense of quality of authority does not mean he is more likely to learn magic, just that if he could perform it, he would be very good at it in comparison to even other artonans wizards. Secondly, humans and most other species are not born with the prerequisite abilities to sense and manipulate their authorities, apparently it can be taught and it can be learned. Those similarly have no correlation to the frequency in which non-artonans avowed develop an authority sense. Even mother stated in the mother chapter that other avowed of different species have gained an authority sense, but that phenomenon is rare, and Alden is the first human. So no, it is not a usual occurrence, and apparently not usual enough for artonans to consider outsourcing knights from other species a viable tactic to increasing the number of hn'tyons. I imagine the other instances of avowed gaining authority sense were peculiar and incidental and possibly novel enough to note every time it happened.

Sebastian Winter

Looking back on how I wrote my last comment, I think my wording was a bit sloppy. It says in the story that the Artonans know that avowed can become wizards (reference conversation with Mother when Alden affixes). In one of the lessons with Joe (I don’t remember which one) Joe says he thinks he could teach Alden but wouldn’t (in a later chapter, again i don’t remember which one) Alden thinks about how only a child like Kibby would help an avowed gain authority sense, because of the pain and suffering it creates. All this indicates that avowed getting authority sense is not only not unique, but not something beyond the realm of Artonan understanding. When I wrote that Artonans know how to turn avowed into wizards, I meant that Artonans know that avowed can, and most likely have a theoretical understanding of what would be required to do so. What I take from this is that when Alden reveals that he is a wizard, they are less likely to want to take Alden and study him (or some sort of other intensity increasing reaction). They are more likely to pity him. Alden gaining authority sense is him entering a life of suffering and pain that he did not have the opportunity to choose. They may be excited to find out that humans are amongst the, most likely limited number of, species who can gain an authority sense, but at the same time feel sad for him for the suffering he will face.

RogerYoung

The Artonans would be completely horrified if the affixation was forced, as stated by Joe when he was teaching Alden. Ultimately, the humans did agree to the contract, and contracts are incredibly important and meaningful to their culture, so the odd human that really doesn’t want to affix being forced to is fair in the grand scheme of things. The lack of information about what affixation is in general is not something that would concern more than .000013% of the population. I think the avowed population is about 7500000, so I divided Alden by that to get the percentage. And even if more Artonans thought that is was unethical or vital to keep that information away, the “avowed are an existential threat to our species” group would do everything in their power to keep them in the dark. For good reason. Imagine if the Humans had a system that was in their pocket and not the Artonans and wanted to wage war against the Triplanets. Well, earth alone wouldn’t be enough but if the Avowed at large decided to attack the Triplanets with their own systems. The first thing to go all non-combat classes. And then every single class skill and stat point is placed where it maximizes effectiveness, without regard for what the avowed wants because who cares. So everyone would form small combat group that synergies incredibly well because the systems designed them, completely focused on destroying the Artonans. Would the avowed win? Not with the knight, I don’t think, but enough to completely decimate the regular wizard force several times over. Avowed are the closest thing to unfeeling killing machines the Artonans ever came across, simply because they don’t feel pain and have no qualms sacrificing infinite potential for a singular purpose. Granted, a system is necessary for all this, and we have no idea what resources and expertise it takes to affix, so maybe everything would stop dead in the water. Unless, of course there was avowed among them who knew magic. Which Alden is. Just saying that Alden is a very small domino that would have to fall if the avowed ever stuck back. Which is why Alden learning magic would terrify many people. Btw I’m still pro Artonan, I just imagine that this is the thought process in many of the more scared Artonans.

JJ Hunter

@Sky23, I am so ride or die for Stu and Alden's relationship. Call it friendship or whatever feels rightest to you, they care SO MUCH about each other. Alden getting protective of Stu and wanting to validate and support him in his chosen paths, his sense of his own truths is so good. If Stu's past peers won't appreciate the person Stu is shaping himself to be, if they persist in rejecting his research contributions to their shared understanding, I agree with Alden: they don't deserve to keep the writings they shunned to the point of not even commenting at all. Stu's community at the first school rejected him first, and persisted in telling him over and over that they would not accept him unless he pretended to enthusiasm for any path other than his chosen one. Alden can't erase that history, but he can offset it by giving Stu his friendship and curiosity and open-minded interest in Stu's everything - all the gifts Stu wanted so badly from his Artonan peers, thought he had from his Rapport I classmates, and lost to their fears interfering with being there for the Stu in front of them, not just the vulnerable young Stu of their memories and their anticipated future.

Julien

I am confused by what the system said: ‘’ [Can you imagine how surprised everyone would be to learn that I had given you the books you already have?] she countered.’’ What was implied here? That he already has access to books? I only remember that he has the basic magic one…

Droog

He received two books, one with basic spells, another about enchantments.

Tori, Writher #1 Fan

I'm with you here. And what really got to me is that the subject he wrote on was “Skills Rooted in Concepts of Connection.” Well, joke's on them, because now there is no one more qualified to make a connection with a single bit of similar life in another dimension, having failed to find connection among his own peers. His knight skill is going to suit him so well.

Kemlion

Loved this chapter; poor Stu 🥺

JJ Hunter

@JennP, Stu's father trusts him. Thank goodness at least one of his parents has come out and given Stu complete and unconditional trust in whatever path Stu feels is most apt for himself. I get the sense that Esh-erdi is quietly supportive in his own way, while not wanting to interject in the art'h family negotiations; he certainly seems to have had a serious, respectful conversation with Stu about Alden's recent difficulties with implied trust in Stu's maturity and standing to help his friend. Emban seems like she may be coming around - she certainly respects Stu's capabilities and his right to make his own choice, even if she has serious concerns about the risks. I do keep worrying about who will be there for Stu as his votary for his first affixation and aftermath. Will he be able to trust any of his peers or his non-hn'tyon family members to help him and not sabotage his chosen path?

JJ Hunter

There's a human loose in the library! It's never happened before, no one knows what the human is going to do next, least of all the human. He's never been in a wizard library, he's as confused as you are. - the Artonan boy Alden interrrogated about yovkews, probably

Sebastian Winter

Emma Mass, thank you for corroborating that Joe thought he could teach Alden magic. The other points are incidental to what I find interesting. Being that Alden is scared that when he shares that he is a wizard it will increase his intensity level, but the evidence, as I see it, in the story is that when he shares he is a wizard he will receive care and support (and not be dragged off to a lab to be studied or some such).

Tori, Writher #1 Fan

I read it as a subtle reminder that he already has her favor, and therefore she would probably warn him if going up was a huge problem. I think she's encouraging him to go up without explicitly saying anything that would use up a favor or count as direct manipulation. She's just giving a bit of perspective, because in comparison to the surprise of his other secrets, any surprise people have at finding a human on the top library balcony would be normal surprise that he can talk his way out of.

Robert Mullins

Between the foot bone, these books, and his books from mother, Alden's got a full shelf of things that he could never give a reasonable explanation for having. Not to mention the 3/4 different pieces of magical jewelry and the flying cookie. Dude needs a vault for all his stuff.

JJ Hunter

More seriously: wizard library!! Love the supply room, the bits of school culture Alden is picking up from Stu's former classmates and Alden's own investigations, the roundness of the room of recordings with its root ladders and rows upon rows of shelves, the cabinets of youthful research contributions with peer comments, the way each student personalizes their journals with their auriad color and chosen symbols (sigils?). The school community and culture implied by the commenting norms Alden discovers browsing the journals, hungry for knowledge and connection to the wizarding education he wants so much and doesn't dare openly pursue. How viscerally wounded Alden feels on Stu's behalf to find Stu's thickest and final journal wholly devoid of any community contributions, any sense Stu's definitive self-concept explorations were heard or acknowledged as contributing to his peers' understanding at all.

Robert Mullins

`[You could just tell me what’s in the cabinets and if it’s useful to me,] he suggested. [Can you imagine how surprised everyone would be to learn that I had given you the books you already have?] she countered. ` Translated: "Bro, I literally handpicked a magic Textbook and catalogue of enchantments for you and had them teleported to you discreetly. You can climb your ass up a ladder if you want anything else beyond that."

Robert Mullins

`[You could just tell me what’s in the cabinets and if it’s useful to me,] he suggested. [Can you imagine how surprised everyone would be to learn that I had given you the books you already have?] she countered. ` Translated: "Bro, I literally handpicked a magic Textbook and catalogue of enchantments for you and had them teleported to you discreetly. You can climb your ass up a ladder if you want anything else beyond that."

JJ Hunter

I wonder what Natalie would make of a library of recordings like this - permanent carvings of experiences where she creates temporary edible versions flavored with her remembered emotions. I wonder how long Mother has been waiting for someone, any one of her hn'tyons to give her leeway for extraordinary action she could leverage on Stu's behalf to address his increasingly painful social isolation. Like Esh-erdi with his delicate insinuations, she is so very careful not to pressure in discretely enabling and encouraging Alden and Stu's opportunities to connect and deepen their friendship, but her close and ready attention to Alden's inquiries whenever he is on Artonan I and Stu's references to how much time he's spent talking to the System in finalizing his skill choice and self-concept are suggestive, to say the least. Mother wants them to grow into themselves; she wants them to have sure ground to stand on with each other, even if they are still struggling to find better ground with their respective families.

Daedalus

She’s also intended to be powerful for her age, no? Considering she only just had her second affixation, that could be pretty weak in the grand scheme of things nonetheless.

JennP

And how Stu's former classmates act just like human high-schoolers, like herd animals. As a group they all gang up on one outlier individual. It seems like not one of them has thought this through from Stu's view point. They all just join in what the majority is doing

CrispyCritter

Rabbit wizards are definitely not unknown to Artonans. Alden has even been "recognized" as one; that's his (foreshadowing) costume at the Leafsong party! Unusual for Avowed, but not impossible.

JennP

I agree that Alden could be summoned for dangerous missions. Stu tried to assure him that wizards won't abuse Alden because Aldan is known to be connected with such a powerful family, but Stu also said he himself would have to do what he thinks is best for the tri-planets. Including summoning and using Alden without Aldens permission.

cafenacet

It’s like if Natalie makes you a home cooked meal, and then you ask her what you should order off the McDonald’s menu.

JennP

What about the humans? Some if the most powerful avowed, like Lute's grandmother, are absolutely capable of locking Alden in a cell and interogating him to learn how he became a wizard.

Rafał Trzeciak

That’s all true from Artonan perspective. I find it more interesting what would happen if humans learned that Alden is a wizard. Considering that humans wouldn’t have any idea about the pain it causes - I can easily see Alden being pressured to reveal how to get Authority sense.

WannaBeATree

I also think Mother does not want him to know how to do contracts. Only Earth does.

PatienceHoney

JJ - This chapter seems to have triggered you in a personal way. I offer you a virtual hug of comfort and understanding.

CrispyCritter

As far as I can tell, Alden only skimmed part of one book; for the others he just looked at title, date, and the originally blank pages at the end of each that had comments.

Aspiring Moth

the herdcreatures are the votaries wanting Stuart to be like them, and not take the path of the highest onus

Aspiring Moth

@JennP "system, ET me out of here". imprisonment isn't going to work. blackmail and other sorts of mental imprisonment could, but he could just teleport out of any physical prison assuming Aulia doesn't have system cooperation

Llainway

Thankyou Sleyca!

JJ Hunter

@PatienceHoney, your care is always appreciated. I enjoyed the chapter very much (magic libraries! I love magic libraries), and I feel for Alden's yearning to learn, and his protective outrage on Stu's behalf. I have a lot of empathy for Stu's struggles and how knotted up he's gotten over his current social dilemmas, but having strong feelings about that just makes the catharsis of Alden's care and friendship now helping Stu find better footing all the sweeter. I'm proud of Stu for persisting; I hope more of his family and his community come to respect his choices and trust his capability to realize his ambitions.

jg

You're confusing Emban with Evul

Endaris

What is most intriguing about this situation is that the treatment of Stu seems so black and white, besides Enban. But I can't imagine it actually being like that. Who is driving that herd?

John D Jones

Inertia. The physical laws of the universe can apply to social dynamics as well. Ever watch the movie Forrest Gump? Who in Gump's social circle at the beginning of that movie could have predicted the trajectory of his life given that he was of below average intelligence and had braces on his legs? To most of the people in his family/social circle, Stu-art'h is a kind of Artonan Forrest Gump. He's the poor fragile child whose own mother brain-fucked his sense of reality. Of course Stu-art'h can't become a Knight. That'd be like expecting poor dumb, crippled Forrest Gump to become a millionaire who won the Congressional Medal of Honor. And they'll keep treating Stu-art'h that way until they can see him "run."

hhttghlk

I love the observation that Natalie makes temporary edible versions of the magic tomes

Unknown

I can't begin to tell you how much I like your reply, John!

VP

Yeah, but to be honest, if my childhood friend with horrible trauma/maybe brain damage decided that instead of choosing the same career that I had chosen and he originally dreamed of (and he would be amazing at), and instead decided to commit suicide in a long winded manner, I too would try to talk him back to my dream job.

John D Jones

@ VP So... you're another Herdcreature. You're assuming that your traumatized friend can't overcome his trauma and become stronger and more resilient for doing so. You lack faith in your friend. But maybe one thing that you and the herdcreatures in this story have failed to consider is that by constantly opposing and denigrating Stu-art'h's chosen path, you make it MORE likely that he'll commit suicide due to the constant doubt and lack of support. Honestly, I kind of hope that Alden hammers that last point home to the rest of the art'hs.

Stylemys

Loot that library!

puppy0cam

> He waited for the reply, sure it was taking longer than usual. did... did she actually ask the trees how they feel about it?!

WannaBeATree

I thought she waited to increase his emotional response and make him more likely to look at each book, but you answer is too on the nose to ignore . . . I could see it. Her reply would also make a bit more sense.

Aspiring Moth

I saw that as a pause where she wondered what crazy ideas he had in his head, checked his mind to make sure she understood him and his possible misconception, and then finally answered. congratulations Alden, you made a magical super AI go '...huh?'

Francis

This is very selfish of me, but I want to know who among the Artonans are the good looking ones. I always thought Esh-erdi must be, but I wonder about Stu and the Primary

Aspiring Moth

@John D Jones Stuart is way more likely to die than the average Knight candidate, and knight candidates already have a significant rate of dying due to being unable to handle it. his own older sister from who his mourning name comes from is one of them. they aren't being evil and not accepting his decision for no reason, they have valid concerns. and the consequences aren't limited to him. remember how zeridee didn't even want a twinge of sadness to happen to an art't family member due to the weight of their burden? Stuart dying could very well cause the primary to die. Stuart is his son and last reminder of the woman he loved and had to kill

Glitter Rabbit (C)

Alden really needs to address the notebooks in a conversation with Stuart (might be hard without revealing that he gets logograms translated). Their relationship is already a bit skewed due to the secrets Alden is keeping (for good reasons). This would just further tip the scales in the wrong direction.

puppy0cam

good looking by who's standards? or more specifically which specie's standards?

Anthony Lutz

Getting words translated isnt something he needs to reveal. He learned artonan verbal with kibby so its expected he "knows" artonan now. So him learning the written language via regular means is perfectly normal. The flash card style translation is obviously a great way to learn but he can probably read an acceptable amount after reading his spell books for a few weeks

puppy0cam

it's also known that although Alden can read artonan, he isn't very advanced in it either.

Glitter Rabbit (C)

When it is about the notebooks from wizards? I doubt that there is a reasonable explanation for why Alden would be able to read those. Yes, sure, Kibby could have been teaching him but getting that far in only a few months? Not that believable, if you ask me. Academic texts require a bit of a different type of reading comprehension, even if they are 'only' on ethics. This is especially true because Stu's notebooks only seem out of place because Alden has read / skimmed several others. It is just another entry on the 'not so quiet rabbit' list

Middle ground

Alden should have just stayed where he was, with the journals and his commendation out in the open. Then when asked why he was there he could say “I was told this was a library, so I found some books to read while I wait for my friend to finish his chores.” Then just sit back and watch everyone’s head explode. Alternatively, he could pull the journals out in front of Stu and Noh-en and say “I completely understand why you’re angry. These guys have shown no respect for your thoughtful contemplation. We totally should have hid in the forest.” Either situation would be hilarious.

Andrew Reise

Yeah I’m thinking something like magic that creates an immersive illusion or dream state that includes sensory inputs and possibly the emotional sensations associated with a memory of the artist. Not literally an opening into chaos. Even still, the last time Alden thought the system was failing on the bus during the Sinker Sender incident (Waves arc) he had a panic attack, so something like this, if it is a magical impression of the sensations and emotions of the painter during a chaos break, could trigger more than just a mild PTSD response. Next chapter should be good no matter which way it goes!

LadyLark

I don’t know. Alden didn’t have much to do with Kibby for… what was it… 8 months? That’s a lot of free time to learn to read and write a language… plus we never really talked about how skilled Alden is at learning and retaining languages. He could even be a prodigy in that regard.🧐

LadyLark

I think what makes me angry is that these people haven’t really registered that. How they are treating Stu-art’h is the same way his mother treated him. Extreme Overprotectiveness. It’s unnerving and quite frankly very toxic behaviour towards someone who has trauma from an overprotective parent.🧐

Terrestrial_Biped

Honestly, I assume the Knights and high- class wizards can all afford to be good looking by their own standards. That presumably includes symmetrical features, but might involve different aesthetic choices - odd face shapes, colors humans find ugly. Alden have a rather unflattering description of Bash-nor's earthworm colored hair, for example.

Kooikerhondjelover

I don’t think Alden wants a quiet rabbit life. It certainly would be boring. But he is only 16 and has had 4 very traumatic experiences, at least 2 of which were chaos related. So hoping to be prepared and develop to his best abilities makes sense. Not to want to be used at whim by whizzards or others who put him in danger makes sense, too. But he did choose the whizzard & knight way for himself and wants to be helpful and supportive to his planet and friends. I hope he can raise the subject with an adult who can support him further ( Esh?the healer?). At some point in the near future he also needs to come clear with Stu or else there cannot be a real bond of friendship between them. I can so see him, Stu, Kibby, Natalie, Lute, Boe and others join Esh on the long journey in this new spaceship. A long, long time in the future …

Andrew Boyer

“There is no overkill. Only ‘open fire,’ and ‘time to reload.”

Aspiring Moth

is it extreme overprotectiveness when him dying due to affixation is not only a significant probability, but also a potential existential threat to the species as their most powerful defender against chaos could die due to it? this is a nuanced issue. if they weren't taking his decision into account at all, they would have forbidden him from the choice in the first place. that's certainly the most pragmatic decision this is a nuanced issue, but people are reading it as 'mean people not accepting me for who I am'

Aspiring Moth

completely unrelated, but you know those restaurants where the chef prepares food in front of you as entertainment? the anesidoran equivalents are probably much better. cooking or even partially processed food would count as an object, so an object shaper chef with foundation points focused on the arms and hands would make for great entertainment

LadyLark

You see, I get what you’re talking about. I do but like those in the story. You’re forgetting that Stu-art’h more than anyone understands the risks. As someone who’s had my dreams questioned by others. I can honestly tell you that the recurring problem with protectiveness is that people often assume that the person making decisions didn’t think it though. That it was a spontaneous decision. This decision Stu-art’h made wasn’t spontaneous. He thought deeply about his decision. In my eyes, them ignoring the fact that he more than anyone else there understands the risks and that he took time to think through his decision is over protective behaviour and it’s wrong. It’s his life not theirs.

J Reynolds

I don't think so. Evul is the 2761st general. Emban is the one who is affixing now.

Andrew Simpson

I'm holding out hope that if Alden genuinely wanted a quiet life, he wouldn't be getting written about.

Andrew Simpson

While I think this was a very deep and interesting exploration of artonan social structures and Stu's past, I was kind of hoping Alden would find something cool and useful in terms of magic :(

Emma Mass

Being aware of the risks does not reduce your susceptibility to the potential consequences. Stuart may be prepared for them, also aware that is at a significantly higher chance of dying. Everyone knows that too, and are also aware that Stuart thought out his decision. All that means nothing in the face of your loved one dying. You can be miserable about a choice, but still alive. The only people who are left to feel regret are the ones that are not dead.

Aspiring Moth

he might still. he hasn't had a chance to do anything more than skim a few books. if he takes them back to earth and reads them properly, he may be able to infer some useful things. the books on teleportation and attracting life element objects to each other in particular may be useful for playing with the summoning spell at the end of whan-tel's art

LadyLark

@Emma Mass I don’t think I fully understand what you mean and I apologize for that. I did ask my mom for context and she gave me a different perspective on the conversation. She pointed out that being a knight is sorta similar to how boys volunteered for WW1 & 2. How it was frightening to the parents and how it would have taken a lot of strength to deal with knowing your child was going to War, but that they generally had to respect their child’s choice. No matter how they felt about it. The thing is from what we’ve read. They aren’t respecting Stuart’s (I can never figure out how to spell his name.😅😞🧐) choice. They are pulling out all the stops, to stop him.

Aspiring Moth

going by the ww2 analogy, it would be like sending the disabled son of the president to war, knowing that the death of that son would absolutely crush the president and potentially cause him to no longer be fit for duty in war time

Aspiring Moth

arguably all 4 are chaos related body drainer was a U type, and one of the main fan theories is that they are given emergency affixations to stop them from turning into demons mid transformation, due to extremely high chaos succeptability hannah is missing in action on a summons, presumably to fight against demons Thegund is a demon moon with chaos bees and cows submerger incident had emergency chaos evacuations to the point they were preparing for leaving the planet as a precaution

TaborlintheGreat

There is a deep humor in entering a highly secure, top level magic library of the most powerful community in terms of magic, as a non-wizard secretly practicing magic, with plenty of time and opportunity to uncover some very important things... Only to coincidentally beeline towards the student journals of your best friend, skipping all the important magic stuff, and learning more about your best friend instead.

Jazehiah

I am curious to see how the comments in Stuart's student notebooks compare to those of other prospective Knights. Are the other students "gently guiding" him towards research because they don't want anyone to go down the path of "highest onus" or is it just Stu? I expect that no one wants to be accused of pushing people towards the painful life of Knighthood. However, Stu might be getting more of this because of who his father is.

Kim Enteiu

That was my thought exactly; it reminds me so much of the way the paintings of The Watcher that Ariane makes in A Journey of Black and Red (by Mecanimus) are described.

Stylemys

Alden has looted wizarding books from the local populace while traveling. He is finally a true litRPG MC.

Stylemys

First Kibby steals from a museum and now Alden is stealing from a library. They really are like siblings.

no

> After that, he made a reading list, then blazed through it with lots of commentary Alden couldn’t understand without having access to the references. What did come through were Stuart’s earnest attempts to grapple with whatever the moral conundrums were. > It’s a very Stuart journal. Alden smiled. I like it. Maybe just a sentence or two of specifics of whatever Alden's best guess is would be warranted here? I have no clue what kind of moral conundrum would be involved in teleportation, and I'm curious. Plus it seems like a good opportunity to insert some casual worldbuilding/details on stu.

Dalton C Vieira

"He was in a wizard library, unmonitored. How often could he anticipate something this happening?" This line should say "something like this happening."

J Reynolds

Maybe it's like being transported in Star Trek, there's the 'on some level, the original version of you is destroyed, and a copy appears at the destination'. Which is a problem due to the mass-murder aspects.

Emma Mass

I think he was referring to teleportations accidents. There's no ethical way to study them on living creatures without purposefuly creating teleportation accidents who's effects are not well understood but generally agreed to be bad for said organism. Maybe like where do they go? What happens to their body? Do they teleport into other solid matter and die instantly from being phased into another object? Do they disintegrate? Do they disappear into some unknown liminal plane? Maybe teleport into space without an atmosphere? Do their particles get scattered or are they genetically rearranged into something unrecognisable or incompatible with life? What's the mechanism of action? Etc.

Unknown

I thought it was something along the lines of the ability to teleport getting into the wrong hands would be disasterous. It probably already is, so how do you deal with the fall out? How do you keep the criminals from using it in a bad way again or keeping them from escaping once caught? Is it morally right to kill someone for something like smuggling highly addictive drugs or some worse but still somewhat mild bad thing?

Unknown

He could just say he was bored and lso he went looking for a book to read to keep busy and entertained.

denatured

Stu's complaints and his parents' overheard conversations have framed his choice and their opposition as purely focused on Stu. @Moth I really appreciate you pointing out that part of their opposition could be about the consequences to the Primary, and therefore to the known universe. I think I'm too literal of a reader sometimes so it's so helpful to see this perspective. Comments like yours are why I love this book club. Given that new framing, it's interesting to think about Stu's point of view. Does he see his dad as invulnerable, especially after Sina's death? Or is he just a regular self-involved teen, a bit too sheltered, who doesn't see the whole picture? Or is he just that confident in his success and believes his dad will be better off when Stu is a knight? It seems weird that he'd be wholly ignoring the effect this would have on his dad, so does he have private thoughts about it we haven't yet heard?

FeathersFavoriteNYC

Upon re-read, it appears possible that Stu-art'h will use some method he researched in this very journal to help Alden search for the truth about Hannah. Or at least Alden will learn some forensic wizardry theory to pursue the truth by himself. I am myself in the "Hannah didn't (immediately) die" camp although whether she is incommunicado, demonised, went back to Earth to infiltrate SAL or went along any other road Sleyca may take us is up in the air for now.

the btrflyz

Are you referring to Stu's research into teleportation accidents? The system notified Alden's next-of-kin of his missing, presumed dead status due to teleportation failure. There was no word about Hannah at all, after 6 months. To me, that implies her fate isn't the same as his was. Are there popular fan theories about her still being alive?

AFK37115

the system didn't say she died or what happened to her, it didn't say anything. Alden told us that sometimes it informs the avowed's loved ones if someone is dead or something happened but sometimes it doesn't. we suspect the people it doesn't tell anyone about are either still alive off planet and can't communicate due to lack of money or chaos fighting mission, or they went back to earth and either got killed (like manon, people will think she was lost off planet) or teleported back somewhere else on earth and lives there secretly (spying on SAL theory maybe)

Jeremy Goldberg

Deaths in this story do tend to be ambiguous or off screen, don’t they? Hannah, Manon, even that scientist who helped Alden on the Demon Moon. The camera tends to pan away, leaving me with just the faintest hint of doubt. Nobody’s come back from the dead yet, though, so I choose to believe it’s a matter of tastefulness rather than letting the characters lurk around off-screen, waiting to surprise us.

AFK37115

I think we know for sure that the scientist and manon is dead, maybe there is doubt if Hazel can tell that someone is dead but Aulia cleaned it up so she must be dead. Hannah's funeral was held because she had her second assignment off-planet which is a chaos fighting assignment probably, and it is been so long without contact. we didn't actually see her die or fade to black or be told, it is more the humans thinking "she is probably dead", the system didn't say so, her ending is uncertain so I wouldn't be surprised if she came back, either as a human or a demon. or we find out how she died, it is healthy that the humans aren't chasing how or if she died though and that's partly what the funeral was for.

Aspiring Moth

yeah it's much more likely that Stuart was partly inspired to research teleportation accidents by Alden's supposed teleportation failure death than the supposed death of an avowed that we've never seen the two of them talk about

Francis

Actually, now that you mention it, wizards could enchant themselves to have more Appeal probably?

FeathersFavoriteNYC

Yes, I refer to Stu's research that Alden just found. As for theories, these are my own thoughts / notions on her possible fate, don't know what is out there on Discord since I cannot log in temporarily to join the group there. But Alden seems to develop analytical abilities here, and from Aulia's and the Informant's POV we know better than him that there are conspiracies at play that resulted in the Sinker Sender flooding. So it is not inconceivable to see him sleuthing in some future arc.

TaborlintheGreat

There is an entire thread in discord about the supposed detective arc that Sleyca said "I put this plot arc a little further in the story, when it was supposed to happen earlier", as well as Sinker Sender incident. Yes, Alden is going to uncover the Sinker Sender incident.

VP

I think Alden's "death" might have further settled Stu's conviction. Alden died of a teleporter accident, something he spent months studying and also something his future skill is meant to avoid. Alden helped him and then died of the thing Stu was going to make himself stop from happening. It must have felt like fate.

Super Super Supportive Supporter

> I plan to have the next chapter to you on the 31st! One of my favorite parts of the chapter, what are yours

J Reynolds

I hope that everybody reading this has a happy new year. And that 2025 is a good one for all of us. I started reading Soup in June, after reading this review: https://jamesdavisnicoll.com/review/may-be-the-devil and I quickly binged the whole thing. I've kept up with it since. Thanks to everyone who comments here. And biggest thanks to Sleyca, our author extraordinaire!

Kooikerhondjelover

Happy New Year! All the best for you all! Looking forward to see this story develop!

Guus van der Borg

Happy new year from the Netherlands people!

JJ Hunter

Thinking about Kon's skill "Reader of Records" vs. the wizard library here full of record-imbued objects. If Kon's skill is the skill version of an existing difficult spell, did creating that spell come before wizards figured out how to store a specific record for easy access, or did the deliberate record-imbuing come first and generalized record reading come later?

FeathersFavoriteNYC

We are talking different records at the beginning of Kon's skill progression. In the library, objects hold information for everyone to read as part of what they are while Kon reads what any object *is*, not just the information it holds. But it is a powerful skill that may have to do with reading Akashic records at its later stages, and restoring things to their pre-demonisation state is a way to reduce chaos overall... What a great vision from the skill designers! Also dangerous, since it changes the relative position in time of anything restored in relation to the Universe.

JJ Hunter

Interesting take! One wonders if some of the tragedy of Stu's early backstory could also have been successfully mitigated if there had been a hn'tyon available with a sufficiently mature "The Maker of Narrow Ways" skill affixed - would the skill allow safe teleportation to and/or from a destination strongly corrupted by chaos? If Iella-inwer reached Jeneth-art'h sooner, would they have needed to struggle as long to cleanse that world of the origin demon?

Eva

Happy New Year to Slyca and those who wait.

JJ Hunter

We don't yet know if everyone can read the records in the wizarding library - activating them may require wizardry, and Kibby and Quinyeth both alluded to age restrictions on accessing them ('big kids' / 'old enough'). I'm still curious how those library objects are created, and what their origin records actually are - are the 'records' in question memories copied from specific wizards, reality recorded into an object in real-time for later playback, or something more esoteric like reading records of past reality and transferred those readings into an(other) object? "Revert to Reading" implies Kon's skill is reading not just how something currently is, but how reality remembers it has been in the past. He seems to be reading snapshots of past realities in present focuses, with his spell impression permitting him to revert reality back to a selected reading of its available records. We've gotten some clues that reality reversions to a past state can also happen spontaneously - recall that wizard healing can fail by 'reverting' - or be induced deliberately - e.g. Spell of Old Wounds. Definitely agree on both the potential and the danger implied by Kon's skill and related spell impression. Esh-erdi certainly seemed to be quite struck by the implications of the restored floor potatoes...

FeathersFavoriteNYC

It's so powerful even at the early stages, reading *all* object information instead of only the learning content. But imagine the skill's progression towards reading Akashic records. And then using the spell to revert things like chaos incursions. It would also synergise well with BOAB's facette of preserving an instance in time... EDIT: Sorry for the double posting, it seemed Patreon ate my earlier comment and then suddenly it was back....

Sindri

I think the appropriate response is probably an anonymous paragraph about how this is a topic of sufficient complexity and interest that a person could probably devote an entire lifetime to approaching perfection in understanding it without a moment being wasted. But stealing a bunch of books and then losing a bunch of SAN points works too.

JJ Hunter

Kon's level 1 skill is only able to 'read' available records for the last few minutes, no? It's got a ton of potential, but the level 1 version is far from being able to read all records potentially available for a given focus; I expect developing his skill further will expand the time range he's able to read, and increase the range of what he is able to perceive for reading. Similar to Bearer level 1, so far we've only seen Kon use his skill on tangible objects; he may need to acquire a defogging package like Alden's before he's able to apply it to focuses that are not objects (e.g. sentient beings) or perceive aspects that are not tangible (e.g. non-physical) when he reads past records. Do we think Kon's skill is an uncapped one? Putting aside whether Artonans have a concept equivalent to Akashic records, Kon's skill having the potential to eventually access to all past records let alone future ones sounds like uncapped skill developed for decades territory. It may be possible, but would Earth Contract be permitted to directly offer a new Avowed a skill of that degree of potential given the restrictions on the original 300 uncapped skills? Are the Artonans still designing uncapped skills for Avowed at this time? All that being said: Esh-erdi's interest definitely implies some kind of direct use for anti-chaos action, so I share your hopes Kon's skill can be developed enough to realize that potential, regardless of whether it's capped or uncapped. And yes, interesting synergies between Kon's skill and Alden's for combo use and for how they can share learning - e.g. perceptual overlaps between how Alden specifies what burden he's bearing and Kon specifies what reading he's reverting. Thank you for sharing your thoughts! Hope this small avalanche of meta in response is coming across in the spirit intended - chewing over theories is something I really enjoy.

JJ Hunter

Next chapter predictions? (in haiku or otherwise) Human stilled by art Picture of commended one Lost in recalling

FeathersFavoriteNYC

Where there's chaos, its opposite ought to be some form of order, and this includes authority which is found both in nature (the Rapport trees) and society (wizards, knights, avowed). Any form of meta-records should ideally be outside both chaos and order. However, in our timeline meta-records also start cropping up in reality itself (meta databases, embeddings within neural networks). So authority being the medium for the Akashic records in Soupverse may be possible too.

FeathersFavoriteNYC

We are not told about access yet but the process of study in the Rapport school reminds me of a sort of scientific research and publishing. The peer review is much more hassle-free than in our scientific journals at the expense of introducing bias when the reviewers know the author and use their feedback to push agendas. So if this analogy extends to subscription vs. open access journals, we may see both models in the Rapport library as well, e.g. books are open access while cubes etc. have different levels of restriction.

C. Adkins

SOUP DAY IS UPON US! AS ONE YEAR DIES, IT SHALL BE HERALDED BY THE ALL MIGHTY SOUP OF SLEYCA

JJ Hunter

Alden has two modes Quiet and Friend Defender Enter wizard twits

SkySeeker

Trauma rears its head This is not the time or place Alden thinks

puppy0cam

I choose otherwise! Stuart slips on a banana peel Emban threw on the ground Alden gets absorbed into the painting like a horror movie Alden looks at the painting for ten minutes and decided the noise was just people passing by and not people coming up to to figure out what the human is doing. Stuart has a spying spell active on Alden like when Kabir was watching the cafe entrance on matadero. Alden discusses the gremlin with Yenu-pezth

JT

Gib chappy 🦖

SkySeeker

Wizards are confused They are also confusing Flee the scene!

JJ Hunter

No window exit For Stu's guest to Rapport school Best brazen it out

PatienceHoney

Happy New Year! PSA: remember to hug your pets and tell them it was not the end of the world.

puppy0cam

it's been outright stated in the story that the opposite of chaos isn't order. It's stability.

puppy0cam

people around my area were creating firework-ey noises 4 hours early

Nedardo

Stuart's shy misstep Alien peel defies knight Mother's laughter reigns

FeathersFavoriteNYC

Happy 2025, Sleyca & fans! Our favorite writer enters the new year. May it bring her more rest, health, and joyous writing. May it bring us a lot of tasty soup and great, funny duscussions!

Robert Mullins

Can't believe Sleyca is a year behind schedule.

jg

O ye of little faith Cooking is the chef Out , out of the kitchen!

Kooikerhondjelover

We have been lucky: it was so stormy at the North Sea that the fireworks were only very limited and maybe 30 minutes. Great start in the New Year for our dogs!

WannaBeATree

we had some people exploding what must have been some kind of small handgranades. knocket a few small windows out from multiple meters away. streets look like garbage as well. even heared firefighters and ambulances drive by during the night. It is a miracle that society functions at all if this is how people behave when they know that they can get away with stuff.

WannaBeATree

Well, obviously the next day only starts when you go to sleep and wake up. :)

JJ Hunter

Auriad purple Auriad blue Alden is snooping Wistful for Stu

Jim

Happy New Year!

JJ Hunter

Hope sleep found you, Sleyca! All the funny-mean teasing aside, we will be happy for next chapter when it comes, and we'd rather it be late and you be well than the inverse. Wishing you and the community rest and joy of the new year; thank you for your many gifts of words that keep giving.

Nathan

Thanks Sleyca!

세희

Happy new year, everyone! May you be granted good fortune.

Michele Goulet

Get the feeling Alden is going to blow up at someone soon in support of Stuart. He's getting the ammo he needs now and his fuse is only so long when it comes to his friends.

Mickey Phoenix

Typo: [How often could he anticipate something this happening?] "like" is missing between "something" and "this".

Mickey Phoenix

> a journaler wanted him to experience the logogram for “hominess” simultaneously with a thought they’d had about laying animal skins out in sets of two This was made *even funnier* by my initial misreading of "hominess" as "horniness"...

Rachel Becker

So sad that the journal expressing Stuart's interest in connection is the one that shows his lack of connection with his classmates so glaringly :'(

JennP

He asked for time. Time without stress. He'll get there