Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout
haven't archived this post yet. have a subscription? use the importer!

Downloads

  • Super Supportive 269 (edited).epub

Missing 1 file.

Content

Edited (epub updated): January 25, 2026

******

Snow XI

******

“What a frown you wear, Stu. And so late in the night. Are your husenots causing you trouble?”

Stu realized he had been frowning, and gazing for longer than he’d intended through the floor of the room that held his husenot collection. Stepping in here to check that nothing was out of order was one of the things he liked to do before sleep, but he’d ended up lost in thought.

“No, Calassa Mom.”

She was probably on her way to bed, too, and she’d stopped at the open door when she spotted him. The dark red robe she wore had been one of her favorites ever since he’d first met her. Of his father’s spouses, Stu was closest to Olorn and Veln, but Calassa had her own place in his rearing. She was more likely to criticize his management of himself in social situations than the others. She was often the best person in the house to go to for stories about Iella. Asking for her help with almost any school assignment was bound to be fascinating, but it would take thrice as long as talking to his other parents about the same thing and sometimes result in follow-up lessons days later. 

“I’m fine, and so are the husenots. I was thinking about something else.”

“Would you like to combine your thoughts with mine?” she offered. “I have time to listen if you want my ears.”

The questions that had begun to bother him after his latest talk with Alden approached his lips.

Why is Alden behaving oddly? Does it have something to do with how the ambassador treated him and the other Avowed? If I have done something myself to make him behave oddly, what is it? How do I make it better?

“I would like to keep my thoughts to myself tonight,” he said. “Thank you.”

She nodded. “Sleep well.”

He listened to her footsteps fade down the hall, feeling regret. She might have answered his questions easily. Even if she couldn’t, it would be a relief to confirm that they were difficult questions and sensible ones, so that he wouldn’t worry he was missing something obvious. 

But to ask for her advice about this, he would have to explain what he was up to in the manuscript library. Most of the unusual behavior from Alden was a sudden and inexplicable lack of enthusiasm for talking about his skill, which he had always been eager to talk about and practice with Stu before. Calassa might try to tell Stu why he shouldn’t research skills for Alden, or she could say something else even more disappointing.

I should have given her a chance not to say something disappointing. She cares about me. 

He looked down at the husenots again. He had placed a few particular ones in prominent positions when he returned them to their habitat last time, and they were still there. Stones that represented things he was confident in. A red one for a friendship he knew he wanted to make stronger. A black one with a white stripe down the center to remind him of difficulties he’d endured and how he’d been changed by them. A purple one for a day he longed for in the future, when he would greet his father as someone who walked the same path.

And I’ll tell him I’m all right. You not only raised a child to adulthood, but to knighthood. I am well. I can walk with firm steps beside you all now, and you can rely on me as much as anyone else. We’ll make this universe a better place together.

Even if I started from far behind. 

Even if I’ll have to travel part of the way on my own.

Stu still listened for Calassa, but she’d gone too far. The loudest sound in the room was the trickle of fresh water into the husenots’ pool. 

His eyes lingered on the red one. 

I’ll call him again before bed. To see if he’s behaving more like himself now. 

And if he was still being odd, Stu could ask him why directly. It was blunt, but Alden was not someone who was offended by plain communication. And plain communication would strengthen their friendship. If there was a problem, they would solve it together.

Stu liked this decision. He headed up to his room to make the call.

******

******

******

Alden had thought he’d have a day or two before another talk with Stuart. He’d been wrong. Not long after he’d made it back to Celena North, Stuart  had called him, on a mission to understand him better through gentle interrogation. He was very empathetic and caring, very eager to help, as he stabbed Alden with a hundred pointy little questions.

It was over now, but Alden was still bleeding out.

“I realized after talking to you that you didn’t answer anything I asked about your skill. Do you want to talk about it now?”

In his bedroom floor, he pressed his body up, trying to calm down by analyzing his pushup form instead of reliving the conversation.

“If not now, when?”

He should have expected this. Stuart had heard him say he was having a bad day and not focusing well, and he’d been temporarily distracted by Alden bringing up the stupid countdown timer. But Stuart was also in possession of a written list of questions he needed Alden to answer so that he could move forward with his research into what spells and skills would be good for Alden

A motivated Stuart holding a list and working hard for the sake of his friend’s existential wellbeing wasn’t an opponent who could be dodged for long.

Apparently, he was an opponent who could barely be dodged for a few hours. 

“You’re still coming over when I’m home from school this weekend, aren’t you? Did you finish writing down your recollections about what happened when you saved Zeridee-und’h?”

Stuart was confused.

He had good reason to be confused.

Before now, Alden hadn’t shown many signs of wanting to avoid sharing when it came to skill-related things. They’d practiced for the bokabv together. Played catch with balls of dirt and leaves. Made a kickass puddle shield with an authority assist from Stuart that Alden had been undeniably thrilled about.

“You’re being odd about this, aren’t you? Is it still about feeling like you can’t do anything for me in return? You’re not mad at me for some reason?”

Alden was on his twenty-fifth slow pushup. They weren’t working. Maybe he should try a handstand like Haoyu.

“Is what happened with the ambassador troubling your thoughts? I’m sorry I criticized you for bowing to him.”

He could put on Olorn-art’h’s earring and wear it all night until it mushified his brain. Maybe that would make him forget how standoffish he must have come across in response to some of Stuart’s requests.  

“Yes, you’re clearly being odd. Just tell me why. I want to help.”

He dropped out of his pushup form and lay facedown on the rug. In the end, he’d lied with the most truthful and distracting lie he could pry out of his mouth.

He’d told Stuart that he was being odd because he was thinking about Goldbush more than usual ever since Stuart had brought up the fact that they wouldn’t be able to talk much when he was working there. Alden told him he was wondering if Mrs. Zhang-Demir might have been there, wondering what Ryada-bess and her squadmates had done there, and worrying a lot about what Stuart himself would do there one day soon.

All of that was true, but it wasn’t the source of his current behavior. Lying here breathing in rug fibers, Alden couldn’t think of many excuses he could have given that would have been more decent to Stuart. At least this one had led to talk they both cared about and not something that was a total waste of time.

Stuart said he was uncertain what his squad situation and assignments would be when he first became a knight. He confessed to being apprehensive about it but said he planned to respect the advice of his elders about his placement until he’d proved himself to them. It was nice that Alden worried, but unnecessary. 

“I’d go there even if I was choosing the path of a votary,” he’d pointed out. “To provide support and learn better how I might help knights in the field.”

“I knew that. I just hadn’t started making detailed mental images of what you’d do there.”

“I hope I’ll be assigned to help a group of knights clear a patch. Usually, some people hunt demons, some repair the environment, and others facilitate the accomplishment of those two objectives in whatever way suits their abilities. It depends on what the specific area we’re placed in requires. If you wish to make a detailed mental image, you should imagine me doing to a demon what I did to the things I sent the keda bean through. Because I’m sure I’ll try to manage that while I’m there.” 

He’d said that with a concerning amount of pep. 

Then, possibly in response to Alden’s obvious lack of pep, he’d suggested that they plan to do something fun and extravagant together upon his first safe return from blowing holes in all the demons he could find in baby knight hell. 

“It will give us both a celebration to look forward to during whatever hardships we may face!” he’d said.

So Alden was supposed to be thinking of extravagant activities that he’d like to experience on the Triplanets. Something really blissful he could enjoy daydreaming about while mutated monstrosities clawed at Stuart’s being and ate his arms and legs. 

Oh man.

The other knights would coddle Stuart too much. He’d go out into the worst part of the Goldbush chaos wanting to prove himself and die. 

Or the other knights would think of him as a weak link destined for a short future anyway. They’d leave him behind when the going got tough, and he’d die. 

One of his siblings, trying to protect him, would die, and then he’d get depressed and die. 

He’ll aim Maker of Narrow Ways at some funky demon with chaosy reflective properties. The skill will bounce off, hit him in the face, and…he’ll die.

At least then I won’t have to think up the least hurtful lies I can tell him anymore.

And there was the sharp truth inside that kept growing larger and more painful with every passing day. Alden couldn’t talk about his skill because of the damn tattoo, but there were other secrets he could share that he was choosing not to.

“I’m done, Wummy,” he said into the carpet. “Kill me. End my suffering.”

Unfortunately, the wombat had always been a pacifist. 

******

******

[Alden: Boe, what do you think would happen if the Artonans found out about me being a wizard? I know we’ve talked about it some, but being serious…what do you think?]

[Boe: Why?]

[Alden: Because I’m asking. Don’t freak out. I’m not about to run off and announce myself to the Grand Senate, but I wonder about it. And you know why. Best and worst case scenarios. Take your time.]

[Boe: Best case is they decide to play you up as a once-in-a-century marvel. They send you to wizard school for thirty years to make you educated, and when you’re not in an alien classroom, you’re being paraded around various planets. Maybe in your fifties or sixties they let you come back here to live, but by then, you’re basically a tall Artonan. Or you’re forced to act like one, anyway, because it’s too inconvenient for the Triplanets if you try to be anything else. Some humans call you a traitor. Some worship you. You have to travel with a security detail.]

[Boe: The worst case should be obvious to you. Do I really have to say it?]

[Alden: They murder me.]

[Boe: They wipe out humanity and use Earth as a vacation destination.]

[Boe: You said worst. You being murdered isn’t the worst.]

[Alden: Thanks a bunch.]

[Boe: I don’t know why you’re using the sarcastic font when you asked for this yourself.]

[Boe: Hey.]

[Boe: You good?]

[Alden: Yes. Just torturing myself a little.]

[Boe: Stop being an asshole to yourself, asshole. Wasn’t this supposed to be your time to explore positive new ways to live your life? Do that.]

[Boe: Wait at least a decade before you make any decisions about the wizard thing.]

[Alden: Yeah. I know.]

******

Comments

Super Super Supportive Supporter

AHHHHHH SLEYCA how could you do this to me, my sleep schedule, my mom, her sleep schedule, my best friend, his sleep schedule, and Alden? (i haven’t read the chapter yet but im sure something happens to alden)

jg

😊

Flying Goat

Typical. Maintenance is never completed on schedule.

cafenacet

What we were expecting: more Stu plotline What we got: artificial wombs

Jinjitsu

One of these days we really need to get an alternate font for the mental chats. We need to witness Aldens creativity.

SkyGold

The "and three quarters" really isn't selling your case Alden

puppy0cam

Take all time estimates, double them, and *maybe* you will have an accurate assessment of how long it will take.

PhoenixPax

Stu POV! Stu POV!

GreatSwordsmith

Dang, this chapter really feels like a burger where someone removed the meat at the last second. You can feel the hole where the juicy important choices were, and the bun/condiments really don't satisfy on their own

PhoenixPax

>>> So Alden was supposed to be thinking of extravagant activities that he’d like to try on the Triplanets. Something really blissful he could enjoy daydreaming about while mutated monstrosities clawed at Stuart’s being and ate his arms and legs. Alden is just not getting a break. Mwahahahaha!

Jess

Stu is such a good and thoughtful friend. It makes me wish Alden was allowed to punch Joe in the face.

Lyssur

Why would a car be safer than the Nine-Edged Son Whose Own Mother Forsakes Him?

Lyssur

Very amusing that Alden is more scared of preserving a fetus than he was in preserving Kibby or Zeridee. Then again, in those cases he was the only one who could help, here he isn't. He has the ideal skill for it, though. And helping like this will probably make him feel better about himself.

Catherine

Poor Alden. You can really feel his frustration and resentment of the situation he's in at the start of the chapter. Boe's take was interesting too. I'm curious about what happens with the artifical wombs and the delivery.

Catherine

For some reason autocorrect changed wombs to bombs... that would make for a quite a different story!

Catherine

When flying he'll get hit by the wind and make it more likely for him to drop the artificial womb. That would be my guess.

Matsc

Good lord man, just start answering the phone shirtless until Stu sees the tattoo!

Dervish

I'm so glad for the new chapter. Of course, I not only want to see more of Alden & Stu coming to a new normal around Alden's "strange" behavior, but now I also want to see more about the artificial womb - although I fear I'd be eager to pepper the author for MORE DETAILS PLEASE! I *think* Stu has enough information to know that Alden has a tattoo and who it's with. He's been with him for long enough that he can tell Alden is reacting oddly. Can Stu put the pieces together? (And does he do so better than I do? Because I'm really bad...) Also, Boe has *got* to get that secrecy tattoo so he can learn that Alden wants to be a knight!

Daniel Keogh

Make the choice! Reeeeeeee

Dervish

Hmm... does this mean Alden's birthday is in March? (ed: Almost the) Same as me!

sebsebs

Feels like I'm watching pressure building up and up and I'm spying behind my door the moment it'll explode

YeetimusMaximus

I love the story but im going to be honest, I dont think many people will be dissapointed if we miss the gym maintenance arc. Im sure itll be lovely if you do end up posting it, but id much rather just have some time pass (a few days/weeks) and have us be closer to the events that have been talked about and for the past year and a half and have them be set properly in motion.

Anthony Lutz

Wummy would make an excellent combat wombat, its unfortunate he's a pacifist. Maybe if Wummy is preserved at the time it wont count against the pacifism when used for smacking down speedsters.

Chas Becht

"The questions that had begun to bother him after his talk with Alden a approached his lips." seems to have an extra "a".

Taitenator

The yell in Alden’s throat… it’s growing beyond his ability to contain…

Kim Enteiu

As if stealing turkeys wasn’t enough, now he’s out here mugging storks. Are any birds safe?

bradley foster

Sigh. I’ll be back in a year or so… I hope you find a way out of this cowardly corner you’ve written Alden into.

FeathersFavoriteNYC

Is it just me, or Alden's next adventure might be escaping a setup of some sort, or even abduction/assassination attempt? He is being sent who knows where on an errand that the other wizards don't see as important. Then he learns it is about life and death. But if an unborn life was at stake, would everyone be so negligent? Clearly, someone somewhere is lying. Also, the writing is suggestive: when he was told not to go to the hospital but to a building nearby, he didn't feel anything wrong. Then there's the lack of receptionist in the vault, or anyone at all except strange guy. And the chapter built up to why Alden is in his head about the tattoo, Stu and the world, so he doesn't register the weirdness. And shady guy keeps him distracted - acting condescending, giving shocking info, and then enticing him like a magic-loving child to go in. I smell a cliffhanger. What do you guys think will come next? Will this be a swift retribution from Trash-nor, or have to do with his overheard mumbling about the Primary and Alis? Or something else altogether? My guess is Trash-nor, whose mental picture of Alden is similar to how strange guy treats him like a child. [Edit: and if I'm right, what will happen next? Will someone disable him physically, or try to sway him so Alden can't text for help? And trigger Esh's emergency ET to Matadero? Is Drusi still watching him? Will he use his auriad? Or emit an authority cry that Lind will recognise?]

Aidan Scullion

Is it only me that feels the story is still a bit stagnant. Nothing is really happening. I get that Allen is worried, he has been for about 50 chapters. Can he please make a decision? He could get Kibby to tell Stu. But please introduce some progression.

Eva

Anyone else get a small Adrian Mole pop up in their heads with the "and three-quarters"?

Kate Yen

He cannot take any action with the intention of leading Stu towards the correct answer. If he thinks of clever ways to resolve the tension, those ways are immediately forbidden as he thinks of them

Cole

I feel like we are deviating again from the plot/story sleyca. Its fine to retcon/remove past commitments that aren't needed anymore, I think the story needs a good 15 chapters of getting back on track to something happening and some semblance of destination to were we are going.

Sleyca

Thank you. It originally said "Alden a while ago" and I didn't delete quite enough words there!

Siobhan Hokin

Ahhh! He just got berry-picked *again*! An Artonan just fundamentally misled him, putting lives at risk, when he's been wrestling with the after-effects of what happened last time someone did that. He needs to look *harder* for smudges. I wonder if he'll notice.

Catherine

I absolutely would love to see the big events that we have been waiting for but I would actually like to see the gym maintenance too. Its a big part of the reason CNH let Alden into the school and so I'm interested to see how it plays out. I don't need or want it to be a long part but I would like to see what happens.

Kooikerhondjelover

I did like the previous chapters with sufficient progress going on. This one feels a bit dissatisfying. I could do without the hospital scene unless he meets Joe in there and finally confronts him . Oh well, looking forward to Monday/Tuesday.

Kate Yen

So many faithless commenters! I'm here because I trust Sleyca... and in my opinion, transparency about the writing process doesn't equal an invitation to nitpick said process. (You can say whatever you want, of course. But it seems to me like this is a good way to not get as much transparency in the future) Anyway. Forgive the meta comment, my next one will be about the story

Cole

I really like this story, but I feel like since a while it's been bogged down by past "plot" commitments, its been December/November for so many chapters now and I feel like it needs movement or direction

Casey

Mini fanfic side story: Meanwhile, on Artonina II the Autobot Bumble Bee from resource world Cybertron is getting his vocal cords fixed. Probably for best, since there was on radio with music on his home planet. The Artoninas found megatron on earth and just froze him harder with magic. Decepticons lose by default. Artonians help the Autobots make artifical wombs and they no longer need the cube! Do you think the Artonians give Bumble Bee a stinger? Ahh... whatever, he's my favorite anyways. And everyone lived happily ever after.

Kate Yen

Here's my hail Mary prediction: Stuart is increasingly onfused by Alden. He'll seek insight from others - not his parents, who might use it as an opportunity to disapprove of their friendship. Not Alis or Esh or Lind. And of course he has no way of asking a human. I think he'll ask someone with unique insight into Alden. Someone who knew a different Alden at a very different time and place, and who has unique insight into humans. Stu is going to ask Ro-den to help him understand Alden. I imagine it'll be quite the confusing conversation for both of them.

WannaBeATree

I love how the chapter ended. Alden was tricked by an Artonan. He probably does not realise who Alden is. Which is a good lesson to remember for him. Even for Artonans in the know, the ones working *under* them might not be, but still making use of their authority (in a status sense)! :) A job not going through the System should have been an immidiate red flag for Alden. Maybe he still does not think of Earth as being on his side? I like how Alden made requests for the job, this time. Brings back memories of how he handled the Mish'nen. I love even more how the one's in need of his help are refusing his help. The guard stationed there was telling. It feels as if womb vaults are more important than the story portrayed them. A fantastic event for his choosing season! :) Also interesting how, no matter which job Alden chooses, there will always be some side job, that concern jobs connected with the one he is doing. By accepting some and declining others, by taking on responsibility or refusing it, he is automatically funneling himself into the niche that society thinks he will be most usefull at. If he takes on task requiring responsibility, he'll get more of those. If he accepts danger/stress, he will be given more of those. It's a natural escalation, untill he hits his limit. I think the choosing season might be about if Alden wants a job, where he will be able to do any and all side tasks or a job, where he will need to refuse some. It's about having the strength to refuse other people and yourself. Why not the other way? I don't feel like anyone who would need strength to *accept* a job (instead of refusing), would go for a knight job (or similar).

Frederik

I feel abit lost in Aldens endless introspection…

Terrestrial_Biped

*waves* Thank you for the note about the gym maintenance! I and my weird way of engaging with your fiction appreciate it. For anyone else who wants insights into when we are and what is happening: Here, have a timeline! https://coral-sheree-56.tiiny.site

Bruno Salque

I don't get it : next chapter will be next week ? Thanks for the chapter, not seeing Alden telling Stuart begins to feel like a drag

JJ Hunter

I feel like an experiment is being run on Alden (and us) on how much narrative tension one character can contain before the yell in his throat explosively releases, and each time I think we've hit Peak Tension you crank it up several degrees more. I'm writhing in 'aaaaaargh' right along with Alden and it makes me want to go punch something, or run a marathon, or pull out my paints and externalize some of these feelings. So excited for seeing the artificial wombs! I've been a big fan of variants thereof ever since falling in love with the Vorkosigan Saga and their uterine replicators; the social implications of not forcing people living with ovaries to do all the child bearing with their own bodies tends to be fascinating. Every technological breakthrough in reproductive tech tends to have tectonic effect socially - it challenges how people conceive of what it is to be human. Alden's worried about getting exiled from Earth? He's about to meet some real test tube / magic petri dish fetuses who are just as human as he is, and have people willing to attack them as if destruction could prove otherwise.

Robert Mullins

The 3 problems with this chapter are that. 1.) it ignores the cliff the last one ended on 2.) it shows Alden directly stalling or misdirecting from the plot element we are most excited about. 3.) it introduces a new plot that is not clearly related to what made readers feel like progress was happening on the things they cared about.

Joshua Flowers

So we ended the last chapter with Alden at Joe’s doorstep and then he bailed and got a job elsewhere while feeling sorry for himself… I feel like I got a rug pulled ngl

Sleyca

Moving this "Writing Update" note down here into the comments section. I want to convey info that might be interesting, but sometimes it feels like a bad lead-in to a chapter. This one is so explainy, and it makes people starting their read think about the very gym maintenance I deleted because gym maintenance didn't belong in your thoughts this chap: "For those of you who keep a close track of the story's internal calendar, you'll know that this weekend was supposed to be the one in which wizards came to repair the gym. Colibrí made a big deal about it. So Alden should have had to deal with that in some kind of way (no spoilers telling you how he was/is/might). I wrote material related to that as planned, but I wasn't liking how it played with everything else going on here and now. So I cut it, brought some of the next thing that's happening forward, and the date of gym maintenance will be moved. " I frequently write things and cut them when I realize they're not working for me without bothering to mention them at all. This wasn't a unique special moment or writing problem worth making note of except for the fact that there was a very specific date given for the gym maintenance earlier in the story, and I wanted to let the calendar-savvy people who were waiting for it know I didn't forget it accidentally. Definitely don't put much brain power into whether or not I should have added gym maintenance now or what it should look like in the future because it's just a little thing on a post-it note I'll figure out how to use in a different way. Right now I'm thinking harder about whether I should have ended the previous chapter right after the scene where Stuart tells Alden what Jeneth-art'h said to him. I think I probably should have because that image of Matadero sinking as Alden listens to him is emotionally resonant and bookends the chapter (It would be nice for him to be staring at the timer at the beginning, realizing it's useless right at the end.) I have a lot more options than usual for where to break these recent chapters because they contain more, smaller scenes. I think for you all reading every several days, instead of bingeing and getting them all as more of a long continuous flow of scenes, the breaks make a difference in shaping the experience.

Robert Mullins

I think most people interpreted last chapter's ending as an intentional cliff to build excitement for a discussion with Joe this chapter. But then the story treats it as if Alden standing outside Joe's door was basically irrelevant. Not in terms of character or overall narrative, but in terms of what readers should be looking forward to.

Daniel Andrews

Somehow Stu will get thrown off the trail or respect Alden’s silence too much to investigate further.

Terrestrial_Biped

My guess is the job is entirely legitimate, even if Panna-ser was being weaselly about it. Alden gets to see some neat magic equipment and meet more people who can tell him about working in healthcare. Maybe after they've heard about his skill and watched him for a bit, they agree he can deliver the womb, but only with strict adult supervision as he does.

Marcia McGinley

I'm glad the chapter ended with Alden involved in something else. He's been doing the proverbial shuffle on the side of the pool wondering if the water's too cold to jump in for so long that mostly now I just want someone to give him a shove. Especially since the last chapter had him actually at Roden's door ready to act.

Julien

Did you play Death Stranding recently and want Alden to be your outlet, with the womb transport and all that? Haha

puppy0cam

> [Boe: The worst case should be obvious to you. Do I really have to say it?] > [Alden: They murder me.] > [Boe: You said worst. You being murdered isn’t the worst.] I mean, as far as the "being a story based in fiction" part goes, its basically the same thing.

Jason Harpster

Giys worried for nothing, the Rabbit is OVER QUALIFIED.

Bzzt

Best part of the chapter was the Stu interlude. Made me so hopeful and excited. He can’t keep dodging Stu forever. But If I had chapters saved up I would probably just skip ahead 5-10 and see if I need to backtrack unfortunately

Isak Mark

Why the build up in front of Joe's room if it became irrelevant?

Guus van der Borg

I've said it before multiple times, and I usually get snowed under by comments 'explaining' why I'm wrong, even by Sleyca herself at some point, but damn, Alden is making his own contract a LOT more restrictive than he needs to. Almost the same way Mother talks about skills. Yes, there are very real limits, but that means all the more that you should not add your own. Alden needs to either become a lot better at mental gymnastics or, as is my current opinion, a lot WORSE at it. The restriction was: “Ah, I would like to clarify a point. Today’s lesson is going to be special, you see. And I would like you to confirm specifically that you will not, through any means or by any permutation of interpretation, intentionally reveal the information I’m about to disclose to you to anyone else of any species without my permission. Ever.” Keyword here being 'intentional'. Plus it only being about the things Joe taught him. For one, an old thing that still bothers me in this sense is Alden being shut down hard by the contract when he nearly excitedly blurted out the name 'Bearer of All Burdens' still makes no sense to me. It was by no metric 'intentional' nor 'something Joe revealed to him' Second, he really should just be able to say 'I can't talk about this' as long as he's not doing it with the intention to lead Stu towards the information. His current idea about needing to 'act odd' in order to not reveal this information should be entirely equivalent to just saying 'I can't talk about it'. Neither scenario would be done with the intent in mind to reveal this information. Sure, he might make a reasonable guess that Stu might use that as a lead to find something out, but he should be smart enough to know that his odd behavior will have the exact same result, and yet the contract allows him to do that too. And again, the INTENT is the same, to keep the secret. So yeah, getting a little tired of this. Also, as some other people had mentioned he was literally right outside of Joe's room and could just TALK about it. But noooooo, teenage hormones shouting DENY JOE EVERYTHING!!!!! is apparently more important to him than something he already sees is sabotaging his friendship with Stu. I enjoy seeing Alden do rational things. I enjoy seeing Alden do irrational things. Seeing Alden ALMOST doing the rational thing and then talking himself out of doing the rational thing is incredibly irritating to me. /rant

Terrestrial_Biped

Because people kept saying he should go pester Joe to modify the contract, so the story needed to explain why that was not an option he would even try. Because someone will always misunderstand social dynamics unless they are spelled out in writing, and some people will continue to misunderstand them even then. The section ended in what seemed, to me, an incredibly clear decision NOT to speak to Joe, not a cliff prior to a conversation with Joe.

Hallow

I liked this chapter and I'm looking forward to the next. The whole womb vault situation is hilarious ngl. I really hope Stu figures out that Alden is contracted to secrecy soon. I feel so bad for Alden. I want Stu to find out and then somehow pressure Joe into releasing Alden from some of his binds. Or like imagining Stu getting someone to summon Alden for him and assigning him the task of talking about his agreement with Rodent. I've low-key been rereading again and I always want to cry when I remember the limits placed on him. Like Haunting Sphere is upsetting because like yeah oof, but Joe's contract being so restrictive feels so directedly cruel.

RainbowPhaze

My guy, if people have had to explain that you're wrong so many times you've gotta include disclaimers about it you should probably just accept that you aren't understanding something important

Tarry Higgins

Alden has carried children (Kibby) and badly injured people (Stu) on the verge of death (Zeridee), why would he not say that?

MWF

Yeah, Stu offhandedly mentioning genocidal wizards being less of an issue than expected during the here to there arc was a little concerning. And Boe presumably doesn't even know about that, just kinda assumes it. Somewhere on Alden's choosing season checklist needs to be finding a sneaky way to learn about historical non-Artonan knights, since Mother told him there were some historically. Presumably the Artonans didn't nuke all their planets into ash if the old knight-skills-for-nonartonans are still kicking around.

puppy0cam

With the gym maintenance being moved to a later date, that means there's more time for any potential legislative action to go through from the grand senator to upgrade the gym equipment. After all, Alden made a demonstration of the benefits to the school's use of it right in front of her (at least in the half second it took for the system to teleport her away)

SammyVeeee

The inherent narrative tension of Optimus 'Makes Frequent Speeches About Respecting Freedoms' Prime having to live under the restrictions of a generational magical contract.

Vitor Bosshard

This stood out to me as well. Alden has shown absolutely no hesitation to preserve people who need it. It makes sense that it would come as a bit of a shock, potentially bringing back some of the traumatic feelings associated with needing to preserve people. But the interaction didn't read to me like this at all.

J Reynolds

Clearly, the main questions this chapter poses us is: (1) what emotions get their own fonts, and (2) what would these fonts be? 1) Fonts we have seen so far, with chapters where they are first found: angry - 90 annoyed - 115 emphatic - 245 sarcastic - 269 2) You can't have something too difficult to read or it would defeat the purpose of communicating. Also, it should be distinct enough from the main text to make it instantly clear that this is something different. Angry - OS Underground. Bold and in caps conveys things well, IMO. Annoyed - Kristen ITC. Maybe it should be italicized? I don't see it as being bolded, though. Emphatic - Bungee Inline, maybe? Sarcastic - I'm thinking a font that mimics handwritten script. Maybe Bradley Hand ITC? Perhaps Blackadder ITC? Alternately, their ordinary font that simply aLtErNaTeS uPpEr CaSe AnD lOwEr CaSe. That would require them to edit their text before sending it. Depending on the UI the System uses, of course.

Quex

In a similar vein was the snowball fight cut?

Alf

What are these artificial wombs? Is that for humans? I don’t remember this being mentioned before

VP

It has been a couple times as one of thole things given to humans as part of the contract. One of the gym teachers was in a riot because of one such installation in Berlin.

Catherine

He bailed at the end of the last chapter having thought about why talking to Joe was not a good idea. He turned and walked away into croutons wizard. There was not going to be a chat with Joe today. Personally I would like Alden to talk to Joe but that chapter made it clear it won't happen unless something changes.

David

… we got more Stu plotline though? Most of the chapter was about it

Catherine

I think Alden needs to look into Artonan literature. Surely there must be stories or plays of artonan friends, one of whom had a very secretive contract and how they overcame it. Like we have Romeo and Juliet and all the varying stories based on that. Alden should take inspiration from those artonan stories to figure out how to let Stu know there's something limiting his responses.

zombie

The inspiration idea is good, but I think the tattoo forbids giving hints as well. Alden would need to use his authority to suppress the tattoo - and that's not feasible cause Roden is a scary wizard beast.

Scarlett O'Hare

Yeah the tattoo being brought up again makes sense in terms of Stu catching on that something is weird, but the plot hook was already firmly caught. I am almost sure Alden asked Esh for help in a prior chapter with no payoff yet. Frankly, I just want to move past it, as in we know Alden tells believeable lies and never talks about his skill, or fix it in some way.

Guus van der Borg

I'm going to have to disagree with you there. Posting something publicly is an inherent invitation to nitpick absolutely everything about it. It is a major motivation for a lot of people to NOT post most things publicly. Now obviously, I'd be very sad if this nitpicking would stop Sleyca from posting things in the future, but I do think it is very unreasonable to post something and then expect no nitpicking. Just ignore the nitpicks you don't like and/or you don't think will help you. (Especially that last thing. Some nitpicks you don't like might still be helpful regardless.) Especially since you might gain a helpful insight from some nitpicks or some nitpicker might pick a nit in a positive fashion and you find that people enjoy details that you never even imagined people noticed.

David Bailey

I guess I'll put my feelings about this arc up here, since they seemed helpful to others in discord. I feel like the disjointedness, distractions, and "almost" nature of Alden telling Stu are doing an *excellent* job of putting the readers in Alden's headspace / mood about what's going on with him and whether he can live with not saying anything. It is frustrating to read because Alden is frustrated and it seems like he's doing everything else but resolving things because that's what he's actually trying to do. Because he's scared. Right now I still trust that this is all (mostly) intentional on Sleyca's part and there's a payoff (good or bad) when the snow stops falling. I do sympathise with the other readers who are feeling it extra strongly, though.

meowmeow

I really hope you've got a lot of character development(like, exponentially more than the bits and pieces we've seen from his ruminations that have largely been reinforcements of opinions/changes that already happened) for Alden cooked up from this or a big dramatic reveal/destruction of their friendship within the next couple arcs because if not this will all feel very pointless. Without the payoff it will feel more like you are simply writing to try and counter reader arguments around the setup than actually develop the characters. Mind you, I do have a good amount of faith that it will work out in the next couple of arcs. After mulling over my comment I do want to make it clear that I really do appreciate this novel and all the work you've put into it. I get that my comment might come off as harsh, especially in the context of all the other criticism that is coming in around this subject, but I say this out of concern. I don't *want* you to have to deal with people getting annoyed or upset with your writing and I want this novel to be as successful and well-liked as can be. I simply want, on the off-chance that it might not yet be clear(I do think you probably already got it, but I care enough to put in effort for a mere possibility) to point out that there is a serious rising of tension in the story that needs to be resolved in a satisfying way for the readership in a relatively timely manner. Imho as an avid reader and budding writer(for all that means).

Jason Harpster

(fictional cut content) ...It's in use, with a human child??? [CONNECT ME NOW] Womb Director, with who? Not you, replied alden. PANNA-SER, what in the name of Rapport - 1 and the Mother Contract made you think lying to me was a good idea??!!!!!! [AUTHORITY SLAP] I am [DISAPPOINTED] by you. Hangs up. (On the other end of the call) How did he do that, thought Panna-ser raising a hand to the red handmark welt now emblazoned across his cheek.

Catherine

Another option for Alden is to have his tattoo with Esh and use it to ask questions about different types of tattoos and how they work etc. It would give him more info than he has on the subject at the very least. He may not want to actually speak to Esh about the tattoo he has with Roden because that would tell Esh there is something about his skill worth hiding with such secrecy. It depends how much Alden trusts Esh.

KB

A combat wombat!!!! That is splendid.

KB

Panna-ser is so well-intentioned but single-minded. I can imagine an alternate storyline, where, through a series of events, Panna-ser inadvertently destroys Anesidora all because he is trying to prevent people from disturbing Ladda-ser.

Overwhoot

At the beginning of this arc, multiple chapters got retconned because they were just "stirring the characters around". There is no part of this chapter that doesn't feel like just stirring around characters. Don't get me wrong - it's fun stirring and I like the characters, but I have to empathize with the people who feel like this is going nowhere. If this was a different kind of story, this chapter would feel like a prelude to Alden actively isolating or doing some other self-harming behavior which that would spiral into other self destructive choices that might catapult the plot forward. But we don't really see that much self-inflicted self-destructive behavior that isn't just someone's core flaw. Given everything we've seen, I expect that Alden will do nothing to push the plot forward, and that the change will be entirely external. Stu decides to come to Earth, Esh gets tipped off and checks in, Mother sends a message, Stu decides to find new friends. Who knows.

František Novák

Risking a life on unborn child so that his wizard does not have to do the service she promised to do is not "well intentioned".

Ano Ano

You would think the doctor would be pumped if he thought Alden was 12. A 12 year old avowed is probably super powerful.

Overwhoot

Also, FWIW, I think that boring solution for all this mess is for Alden to come out and baldly lie blaming Aulia. In particular, "Aulia Velra asked me to take this skill out of curiosity, and I couldn't refuse for safety and political reasons. I accepted an incredibly restrictive contract of secrecy and can't talk about the fundamentals of my skill. Because of your interest I had to get special permission to tell you this much and I didn't want to ruin our friendship" would just... fix this? I'm sure he'd need different wording, but it would conceptually be sufficient because: - It doesn't reveal anything he discussed with Joe. - It actively obfuscates the information he learned from Joe in lesson one. This explanation would now be less suspicious than his continued avoidance of the topic. - It is accurate enough that Stu would understand and probably stop looking or not notice skills that are too like Alden's. Playing into Stu's biases here against non-Artonans knowing about skills would be an incredibly effective tool. Alden knows and has used similar biases against wizards as recently as this arc. Please note I call this the boring solution because everyone thinking that there is a knowledge-based trick to every situation badly misunderstands Sleyca's style and goals, and from that Doylist perspective a solution in this vein would go against all of the angsty development that has been deliberately added. There is no solution that Alden will find, or that even //can be found// because Sleyca doesn't want there to be. It's just not worth arguing about, except as a fun little toy game. Just like an argument over whether Batman or Squirrel Girl would win in a fight, there is not a correct answer and all you are doing is being mad at each other for no reason.

Overwhoot

This is actually an incredible point. Is the doctor/steward not Avowed? Most people who work with children have a much better idea of how old they are than most adults. It's entirely possible that this person is more like a technician than a doctor, doesn't actually interact with children, and might not even be Anesidora native. Are they a temporary transplant due to the floods somehow? They also don't recognize Alden even from the flying vehicle mention, which means they are pretty out-of-the-loop.

PeasOfCrab

I do like how this chapter depicted Alden and Stu’s conversation. Sometimes we focus on things we said but very often in our internal narratives, we’re trying to review and interpret what was said to us.

Leaf

Ooooh Stu’s building up to something

KB

This is what I think too! *rubs hands together excitedly*

PeasOfCrab

Also, I predict a bit of an authority movement in Alden’s near future…

Skull Leader

It is likely wayyyy to late for me to realize this fact but why is this arc called Snow? They are in the southern hemisphere and it should be currently summer.

Leo Svedman Sundberg

Alden should try to lift his contract tattoo using his skill. It should be possible right, since tattoo's are a form of enchantment and we know you can supress tattoos with enough free authority. He could transfer the tattoo to like a klerm or something.

Jazehiah

Boe was the wrong person to ask about the best and worst case scenarios, but he's the only human Alden can talk to about it. Boe is so paranoid that he cannot imagine an actual "best case" scenario. His ideas of what would be good and bad are also not grounded in fact. The best and worst case scenarios are entirely dependent on who Alden tells and, more importantly, both who they tell and when they say it. But, Boe sees Artonans as a monolith. He does not consider that Alden telling people could ever be a good thing. He doesn't imagine that Artonan ethics might limit the amount of testing done on Alden, or that the Knights might be fiercely protective of him. Gorgon's line about friendship is beginning to prove itself true for Alden and Stu. How close can they be as friends if Alden can't tell Stu what he's already told Boe?

PatienceHoney

I was also thinking of something along this line. Alden could talk with Esh (during the Matadero tattoo would be a good time for it) and he could say that when a certain subject comes up he is unable to even say or indicate that he is unable to talk about it because of the tatoo. He could ask if there is any way, other than going to talk with Roden, that he could get it loosened. I don't think that this line of discussion would trigger the tattoo contract and he could probably get valuable advise from Esh and maybe an assist in going to Roden to get the tattoo relaxed without being as vulnerable as he would be if he went alone. People talk about tricking the tattoo, but I think expert advise and direct action is better.

PeasOfCrab

> The other knights would coddle him too much. He’d go out into the Goldbush chaos storm wanting to prove himself and die. Or the other knights would think of him as a weak link destined for a short future anyway. They’d leave him behind when the going got tough, and he’d die. One of his siblings, trying to protect him, would die, and then he’d get depressed and die. The funny thing is that I bet all this frantic, ungrounded worry that Alden is doing is decently similar to what Boe feels about him.

J Reynolds

Joe smiled. “I am an experienced and powerful wizard. And you’re a clueless fifteen-year-old human. If there’s a disconnect between what I think we owe each other and what you think we owe each other, then my authority over the contract will absolutely crush yours like an insect.” -Ch. 29.

RadioSilence96

Really enjoying these chapters. Alden is spiraling a little but hopefully something screws his head back on. Honestly I could never imagine what hes going through as someone who's holding a secret like his. Something that will most likely change relations between two people's or at the very least change everything about his life. I get why hes dragging his feet. Just as Alden has just been what Stu has needed, I hope when the truth comes out, Stu will be what Alden needs.

Temp One

I'm kind of wondering if Sleyca should consider pausing the subscription and taking the month of December off? Christmas and New Years are coming up, and the two skip days have already been used. Trying to write around those big holidays, especially with all the potential family plans, seems like it'd be extremely difficult to manage time-wise.

Aspiring Moth

skip days aren't a thing currently. we're on a non standard schedule for this arc so that she can get it right. I'm sure she can factor in holiday time to the flexible schedule as is

Support

I see Boe's "best-case" as being best-case for Alden's safety, rather than being aligned with Alden's more heroic (or self-sacrificing) tendencies. Bureaucracy and "Avowed-are-children" mindset to the rescue - Alden will be a lonely object of alien and human curiosity and envy, but at least he'll be safe!

Tifer

WARNING: meta-comment It seems like a lot of the commenters here are approximately at the level of frustration with the narrative teasing that I was at 50-100 chapters ago, and I find that instead of being relieved people openly talk about it, I am concerned that this amount of pressure to perform could prompt Sleyca to pivot too hard from what might otherwise have been planned. Not to say she caves to pressure or to put words in her mouth or anything--I don't know what she thinks about this kind of feedback and am making assumptions.

Bob Smith

Alden visits Stu -> Stu asks a direct question (or many) -> Alden's authority writhes and lets out a cry of anguish (unintentional, a la Zeridee getting stabbed) -> Stu hears

Kemlion

Tftc! Alden imagining a thousand ways Stu can die as a knight….

WannaBeATree

Yeah. Reading all chapters back to back vs. waiting for each one feels very differently. Alden's choosing season might have ended, if we compared it to irl-time. Story time is slower though, so it feels as if Alden is dragging his feet even though he is sprinting. It is unfortunate.

Armo

Thank you for the chapter! It’s such tense reading, Alden’s internal conflict. Pressure building up like steam inside a pressure tank. Really well done, Sleyca! Can’t wait to see how this conflict is released. Mayhaps… avalanche? We’ve already had first avalanche, yes (chapter 121). But what about second avalanche?

Cassie Brooks

I wonder if the Snow we are XI’ing this chapter is both Christmas and also the scene where Sina died? Ultimate twist of expectations during the Christmas chapter. During Christmas season nominally at the time of writing.

Cassie Brooks

Lmao Boe emotion reading Alden and then kicking the shit out of his B-rank friend for not getting that Alden’s doing the same to him.

Goodie

From chap60 “But [Enchantment] made it possible for Alden to remove and preserve only the magical enchantments on an object “At first, this one would mostly be good for making something temporarily non-magical. Or I guess…if I held the enchantment away from its ‘natural home’ long enough…outright breaking it? It sounded like it would be great for busting open magical locks.” Go Alden, use your defogging package to break that magic tattoo lock! Better still lift it and slap it onto Ro’den, it’s only fair! As for having the greater authority, team Alden + gremlin has already made Ro’den sweat way back at Leafsong. Edit- @ Leo S I meant to post this under your comment, whoops

Louise

I love your story. It is the greatest I have ever read, and I read a lot. I'm connecting to the characters in ways I never knew I could. Thank you (my dream is to get a french translation one day, so my mother can read it. She would be in love too)

Cassie Brooks

Yeah!!! I’ve been in a different headspace reading Snow than when Ripples was coming out (stable with a job vs extremely stressed during I think both finals and a breakup), and the slow-paced nature hits very differently. I read and re-read and re-re-read those earlier chapters when it was coming out to try and keep the momentum going in my mind because I was extremely excited for the potential of stuff changing. Reading these chapters that are not about Alden maybe doing something drastic but about answering the questions of “How do you handle being friends with a knight who could expose you for what you are?” “How much is hiding worth to you?” “Can knights be trusted?” “Are you a knight, or are you an Avowed?” All of these are, like, central to the plot of Soup. My expectation is that they will continue to build. And build. Because they matter. Alden might get every chance to hide possible. Even more than we see now, and it would be a good idea. Every chance not taken to be a knight and to tell Stu is another chance that Alden confronts that choice over and over again. Do you think the question he asked Lute about his powers is for nothing? Or the comment that Esh made that they may not always be there to protect him? Or all the different ways life is one layer away from chaos? How Lute doesn’t get that? How Haoyu does? And Esh and Lind too?

Clint

Feels like the Snow arc could go one of two ways: 1) We’re seeing the final part of Alden’s choosing season — Haoyu’s mom represents Alden’s potential future battling Chaos; transporting a fetus-laden exowomb represents Alden’s potential future as a lower-intensity delivery Rabbit. The arc will climax not with Alden telling Stu or getting out of his tattoo, but rather with Alden telling Mother he wants to become a Knight, and starting to make real plans to manage the transition and reveal. Or… 2) Another catastrophe (perhaps a power-wrought blizzard?) is going to strike with Alden carrying an innocent to safety in the middle of a wider disaster with no access to an emergency teleport. (I’m pretty sure snow doesn’t count as Ground element!) I’m hoping for scenario 1.

M

There is no way Alden becomes a Knight so quickly. He might tell Stu about his authority sense (maybe, I'm not completely sure that he will even if the story seems to be moving in that direction) but becoming a Knight? Way too early for that

Clint

Alden needs to place a call to Mother. Or at least Earth. He can talk to them about all of this — from the tattoo to what his life would be like as a human hn’tyon and even potential political fallout for Earth and humanity as a whole. Ideally, he should get to see young knights fighting chaos on Goldbush before he commits, but that’s never going to happen without Mother’s intervention.

Goodie

Snow arc title has been bugging me, and that’s the most significant link I can find, where Stu’arth watches his sister die in the snow. It’s hot at Christmas in the southern hemisphere. (Fun fact- on Christmas Day nearly 20 years ago it snowed on Mount Wellington in Tasmania. Was 30 degrees c at nearby Hobart the day before, so anything is possible I suppose.) Sure there was the occasional comparison to snow at the beginning of the arc and maybe a snowball fight coming up. Alden made some big life changing choices in Chicago’s snowy February when he first affixed and the Mother arc featuring snow, maybe he’s about to do so again.

JJ Hunter

On reread, there's a nice contrast here between Stu declining to share his thoughts with a trusted adult who makes herself available to help him puzzle things through, and Alden seeking out Joe, a no-longer-trusted adult, only to find he's not available and remember Joe probably wouldn't help him the way he wants anyway.

Anthony Lutz

Crackpot next chapter / arc prediction Master Ladda-ser is in cahoots with the < Dominant Humans Society > in their efforts to gain authority awareness. They noticed that Alden has it, so he was sent to the womb vault place with the intention of capturing him and conducting experiments for the purpose of either cloning him or using him for artificial insemination, like Hazel. It was good Alden had practice running on Thegund, because he's again running for his life as the story switches away from slice of life and the choosing season, and hard pivots to a Survival Horror. As Aldens greatest fear comes to fruition, a dangerous situation occurs when he does not have an entruster/entrusted object, How long can he last before he starts spellcasting to keep himself free of captivity. 

Zachary Sloan

I'm a little surprised Stu hasn't considered a tattoo, since you'd think that "people suddenly being weirdly evasive" would be something commonly associated with secrecy tattoos in Artonan society.

J Reynolds

(AU where Joe was in his room and he and Alden get talking) "Have you ever thought of being a wise mentor figure?" Alden asked. "Your bit of 'cheerfully immoral criminal guy' isn't really doing you favours these days." "How would I be a wise mentor figure?" Joe asked, unwillingly fascinated by this bizarre turn of events. "You could tell me to wax on, wax off. You could speak with odd word order. Like 'Train your skill you must, young Avowed.' That could be pretty tough since you're not a native English speaker. Maybe something like 'He who questions training only trains himself at asking questions.'" [CUT TO SCENE WITH LEXI, ALDEN AND JOE] "Why am I doing this again?" asked Alden, trying to balance a hammer on his head. "When you can balance a tack hammer on your head, you will head off your foes with a balanced attack," Joe replied. "Why am I wearing the watermelon on my feet?" Lexi asked plaintively. Joe looked at the watermelon on Lexi's feet. "I don't remember telling you to do that."

PhoenixPax

The difficulty is that Alden's tattoo is a contract between him and Joe, empowered by both of them. Joe already has the tattoo -- they both tattooed themselves, not just Alden. I don't think Alden could lift one side of it without cutting it off from Joe as well, just like he couldn't permanently separate the bowl at Leafsong from the Mother Tree. When Joe overpowered the Grand Senator's Wife's Marriage Contract, he wasn't overwhelming her authority (she was not a wizard), he was overwhelming the Grand Senator's side of it. Joe is way more powerful than Alden. Esh killed the non-active part of the contract, the active (secrecy) part is the part he didn't get rid of, and that's still fully empowered, by both Joe and Alden.

David

“Baby knight hell” might be my favorite three-word phrase from the entire serial

PhoenixPax

Overall, I had a positive impression of this chapter on my first read. I was initially surprised to see so many negative comments. I've been mulling it over and putting on my editor hat since then. @Sleyca, I think you are currently trying to inch safely down a bit of a narrow razor with this arc, in a narrative sense. You've stretched this narrative line out like it's the string of cheese on the hot pizza that Alden remembers when he has the vision of Gorgon on Thegund. Doing that without snapping the reader's patience is tricky, and doing it with a one chapter a week pace means that every chapter has to be reasonably solid on its own. The narrative arc already snapped once, as we've generally agreed, and that's why you started the re-write, redacted some chapters, and slowed down your pace to be certain you're keeping your story on a bearing you are happy with, chapter-by-chapter. Until this chapter, I have felt like you are staying bang on target. So here's a quick preface to my analysis of this chapter: Generally not just every chapter, but every section of every chapter in Super Supportive is either... - funny - vivid (aka worldbuilding and fun and easy or exciting to imagine) - plot-moving - some combo of the above Here's a look at this chapter section by section in light of those three primary constants that keep us all reading and hanging on the edge of our chairs: * Stu and Calassa talk and Stu ponders why Alden is evading his questions I like this section overall, though it gets a touch ponderous in spots. We learn more about Stu's relationship with one of his parents. We get a direct look into Stu's growing realization that something is wrong. Plot moving and pretty vivid. Thumbs up overall. * Alden emotionally reacting to phone call with Stu. I also like this! Plot moving: Alden is confronted with the fact that his stalling tactic is not working and is about to blow up in some direction Vivid: I love how we are hearing this conversation as Alden stewing over it afterward (get it, Stu'ing??). It's emotionally vivid without subjecting us to the emotional discomfort and wordiness of hearing the whole conversation. One general issue: The following two sections are mostly the same info given twice. It's a little too repetitive for me, especially considering Alden also was thinking about this same topic in the same way in, I think, last chapter, and then you hit it TWICE in this chapter: 1st time from Stu: "Most of the unusual behavior from Alden was a sudden and inexplicable lack of enthusiasm for talking about his skill, which he had always been eager to talk about and practice with Stu before." 2nd time from Alden: "Stuart was confused for good reason. Before now, Alden hadn’t shown many signs of wanting to avoid sharing when it came to skill-related things. They’d practiced for the bokabv together. Played catch with balls of dirt and leaves. Made a kickass puddle shield with an authority assist from Stuart that Alden had been undeniably thrilled about." * Alden mentally recapping Stu's description of Goldbush Plot moving: A little bit. Alden finally found a way to get a little more info about Goldbush, which is theoretically helpful for his choosing season. (So why doesn't it leave me feeling better that Alden is getting helpful info?) Vivid: Not so much. I came away from it feeling vaguely dissatisfied. I don't feel like my personal understanding of Goldbush or ability to visualize it grew in any meaningful way. I feel like I got more vivid understanding of chaos field work out of Alden being trapped in that painting in the library than I did out of this passage. The only new info was stuff that sounds like basic common sense (some people cleanse, some are support, etc.). We already got big hints about 'clearing patches' of Goldbush from that young knight at the -art'h household, so the broad-strokes look at Goldbush isn't really imparting anything new to me as the reader. * Alden catastrophizing about what will happen to Stu at Goldbush Plot moving: Good-ish -- Alden is finally thinking about what will happen to Stu alone at Goldbush. Not great though -- he didn't connect the dots at ALL of Stu alone at Goldbush vs Stu with Alden by his side at Goldbush. And that's where I figured out why I only felt good about the Goldbush talk with Stu at first, but it feels less and less good to me the more I think about it. It's the momentary shadow of actual progress, but not the substance. Alden isn't for a moment allowing himself to actually visualize 'Stu and Alden at Goldbush together' despite having a whole conversation about what it is like there. :( In other words, this whole conversation with Stu is implied to have moved absolutely nothing forward in a positive sense for Alden visualizing a future as a knight. It has just fed more negative rumination and stress without the slightest hint of a light at the the other end of the tunnel. Funny Stuff: First real funny bit of the chapter. "I'm done, Wummy..." Got a laugh out of me! * Bare Transcript of Alden Writing Boe Plot Moving: Nothing moves in any useful forward direction. Boe's opinion is exactly what we all knew it would be. Boe's opinion is also exactly what Alden knew it would be. Alden isn't honest at all to Boe about why he's really asking either. Basically Alden just blew some steam off the pressure cooker, and that's it. That is bad, because all it did WAS blow off steam, not make viable progress. It's the opposite of progress, in that sense, by giving Alden an actual real-world action he can take to momentarily relieve his stress and desire for action, even if it isn't a satisfying one. (And by real-world action, I mean the reaching out to Boe aspect. A text conversation is a real choice made in the real world with possible consequences.) I can see it as something Alden's character would naturally do at this juncture, but that doesn't mean it's narratively helpful. Vivid: It isn't. This is a pure text conversation. We (the readers) don't get anything resembling a reaction shot. For all we know, all this conversation did was strengthen Alden's current beliefs that it isn't safe to reveal his wizardry (and even upped the stakes by suggesting Alden is endangering everyone on Earth including his friends and the people he loves). So, this was possibly plot moving -- in the direction of Alden moving BACKWARD. We readers can't tell one way or the other. It kind of sounds like it went backward, honestly. * Alden volunteering at the hospital on Sunday. (This is a new day, I think.) Vivid : It isn't. It feels grey and dreary, not colorful. Alden is implied to be bored in the initial paragraph (He spent most of the morning cleaning things and begging for errands.) Let me paste this next bit word for word from the chapter text: His thoughts went around and around in circles while his hand did the same, wiping smudges off steel and glass. It’s not fair that I’m hiding what I am. It’s not fair that if I stop hiding what I am I might lose everything. It’s not fair that I’ve got a tattoo that makes me hide even more of what I am. It’s not fair that Artonans and humans can just decide important things for me about my own life. Not fair that there are smudges. It. Sucks. He was so sick of the litany. It wasn’t even interesting at this point. Nothing new. Just a broken record.] Sleyca, consider listening to your literal own character, but with one minor replacement: [The Reader] was so sick of the litany. It wasn’t even interesting at this point. Nothing new. Just a broken record. Alden is right. At this point, it feels like beating a dead horse, and not just beating a dead horse, doing it for multiple paragraphs. Plot moving: For one moment we think so... "He tried to point his attention toward anything else. What Lind-otta had said to him [...] What did she say? [...] I think she said, “You can’t fight every darkness or bask in every light, Alden. Accept this, so—” And then the thought gets cut off before it accomplishes anything at all. As a reading experience note: Why are we, the readers, being reminded here of something Lind-otta said, especially without it resolving into anything? It's just whiplash, because she's dragged to the front of our minds for a moment, then banished a few seconds later. She's barely a side character from how little we've interacted with her, which doesn't help with the whiplash, since I don't have a good sense of her personality yet like I do with characters like Esh. I tried to pull her out of my very-minor-characterization-side-characters slot in the back of my brain and then had to stuff her right back in immediately. But back to the thought Alden was attempting to have. Even as Alden is attempting to remember the quote, he's doing it in a sullen way that doesn't suggest he's doing anything a good psychologist would recommend as constructive ('Suck it up and stop complaining,' etc.) Then, the moment he tries to get a little bit serious about turning it in a positive direction, he gets slapped by a purplish hand on the window (and so does the reader)... And we get subconsciously reminded: When Alden has a chance to remake or explore his own vision of a future as a knight, he will never, ever take it. I remember back in the day when Alden made a serious and lasting attempt at reframing his conception of his skill from an ugly machine to a graceful origami. I miss the days when he displayed those kind of emotional skills. It made him fun to read. I can't remember a single time in this story where Alden has let himself fantasize in a positive way about being a knight. He's always imagining it as terrible and life destroying. He hasn't even fantasized about standing as an equal with Stuart as fellow knights. You gave him a wide open opportunity earlier this chapter and it didn't even OCCUR to him to imagine saving or helping Stuart or standing by him on Goldbush. All he was imagining was Stuart dying with Alden not even in the picture. * Panna-ser interrupts with a request Plot moving-ness: So far, it appears to be just a distracting side quest. Too early to know if it's broadly plot-relevant (and by the end of the chapter, we still have no idea if this plot line matters in the long term or not). Vividness: It feels like a reprise of initial Panna and Alden interaction. So, kind of stale. Doesn't really impart anything world-building-wise like it did the first time, when it felt new and fresh. Also >>> “I just wiped the inside!” Alden exclaimed Subconscious reminder to Alden (and readers) that any work that he attempts wiping smudges off the universe is meaningless and futile. Not the type of hint I thought you were trying to drop, unless you are going in a very different direction than I thought with this story. * Alden is flying the Cookie Plot relevance: Descriptions of Alden flying the cookie: why spend focus time in the air when we've already spent so much time flying the cookie in this story in other contexts? Plus, Alden mainly just recaps what we already learned in previous section: "His destination was the pediatric hospital in F, where he expected to stop by a desk somewhere and pick up a broken alien medical device that was delicate enough to require his skill and portable enough for him to fly with. That was what Panna-ser had described to him." Why basically say this twice, once during the quest giving NPC bit and once during the driving scene? The only really new info is that he is flying to F, and that doesn't appear to matter to anything much. For that matter, why make a whole thing out of Alden having a beef with a neighborhood watcher? He can't he just park and walk in the lobby? What narrative purpose is this confrontation moving forward? Why make a point of 'security guard harasses teenager outside a hospital building for an extended length of time'? What kind of medical space doesn't have a receptionist even though it has a comfy lobby at the front door? I mean, it's not terrible in general to have this back and forth with somebody, security guard or secretary or doctor, but I don't feel a great need to spend extended time with Alden sorting junk mail either, and this whole section just feels kind of like riding along with Alden on a minor annoyance wasting his time by gatekeeping him from actual decision-makers. Vividness: We already know about the existence of womb vaults from earlier in the story. We already learned that they are controversial and there have been riots. The only bit of worldbuilding is that the building looks like a lotus, and honestly, it wasn't that exciting a thing to learn. I didn't feel like lotus vs fortress came across as a strong worldbuilding moment because it was only the mildest of embellishment added to information given previously. * Alden gets through to an actual doctor who explains that Panna intends Alden to move a patient not mere equipment Plot moving: I get echoes of Alden getting a task from Joe that he was ignorant of the actual implications and dangers of. Here's the moment that struck the echo of that scene like a bell: "He very definitely described it as an object, and I don’t think he’s stupid, so…he did that on purpose so that I wouldn’t say no." I love the callback! And that's about it for the plot relevance as revealed in this chapter. Frankly, I can't imagine this doctor handing Alden an embryo, based on this whole exchange. So, my first gut instinct was to say this section is a mini-sub-plot that is now wrapped up and we'll move on to other story locations and plots at the start of the next chapter. After all, can you imagine the doctor explaining to an incensed patient what happened to their baby? I gave it to a brand new teenage volunteer because a doctor didn't want to do her job? That sounds like malpractice to me if anything at all happens in transit! He's barely done any high stakes volunteer work for the hospital, and barely even a handful of hours of ANY volunteer work yet. What would that Admin think? The one who let him loose on the hospital and told him she'd be monitoring his judgement? She would probably not be happy with Panna or Alden or the womb vault doc (depending on whether he lets Alden do this, of course). Vividness: The Doctor is obstructive adult number 2. By now, the watcher has already played that role. The doctor comes across as mostly contemptuous and abrasive to me, not funny, especially at first. I'm not sure if the doctor was intended to be funny or not? (Though I'll happily admit “Were there unborn babies inside any of them?” was a banger.) I think the doctor's initial attitude would not be so annoying to me as the reader if we hadn't already done the unhelpful adult gauntlet a paragraph or so ago. If he was obstructive adult number 1, I think I would have found him less annoying and more sympathetic. But even then, it's a little unprofessional of him to mock Alden for his youth the way he does -- and he's a dude we don't know mocking someone we like and respect, which makes us readers want to bristle like Alden does. We also know Alden doesn't really know what he's being asked by Panna. So the request seemed reasonable for Alden when he accepted it. Also, can we say 'foolish teenager', here? Alden learns that an Artonan has given him a job with incomplete information and deliberately evasive intent. And first thing he does is double down on 'of course I'll do it' as a snap decision without working through any logistics (like taking a car) until after he's already doubled down. So for a moment we think we have a subversion of the Alden who said yes to Joe too fast, but now we see he's still jumping before looking. (Except on the one topic we actually want him to take a risk on, of course! And that's the topic he CAN'T look before he leaps properly, unlike this one.) If I was a hospital volunteer and got 'volunteered' to do a solo cross-town medical move of somebody's baby, my first instinct would be to say 'hell no', then only agree if the thing were renegotiated significantly. There is an argument that teleportation is a thing, in case of trouble. But Alden is feeling extremely half baked, young, and unreliable here in this section. In my mind, this isn't Alden moving toward being a hero by 'saying yes to something heroic', it merely feels like he is showing that he's still immature in his judgement. Alden can even tell it's coming across that way himself. It makes me feel like this ending to the chapter is just reinforcing the overall narrative that Alden SHOULDN'T be making big adult decisions like telling a Esh that he is a wizard. (And that theme appears to be the main overall narrative point of this chapter as written, which baffles me thematically.) Summary: I like this chapter the most at the beginning and the least at the end. The whole chapter feels like the engine of progress that got re-started by the re-write is grinding progressively more slowly over the chapter until it reaches a full stop again by the end. There are two possible outcomes to the end of this chapter and the womb vault thing: Possibility 1: This is a side quest with no plot relevance, and effectively ends at the end of this chapter. (Like I said, it feels like the womb thing is basically over at the end of this chapter and the next will start with something totally different in a different venue. In other words, I have trouble imagining the doctor doing more than giving Alden an offscreen tour and then shooing him away.) Possibility 2: The womb vault plotline is going to turn into the 'big crisis' where Alden finally makes up his mind (despite having spent the entire chapter subtly reinforcing to the readers that Alden will never make this choice, no matter how bad it makes him feel). If it's number 1, this womb vault plot line serves no narrative purpose that I can see other than as filler to get something out there. If you're at that point, please say so! The people who are left are on your side. (I don't think you are there, though, based on you taking an extra day to post and other rumblings I have heard.) If it's number 2, then this chapter likely should have been named Avalanche I, not Snow XI, and I think it shouldn't have ended where it ended. (It was short for a chapter to begin with, and there were multiple spots that felt to me like they could have been lightly tightened up.) I think this chapter should not have ended until the reader got the 'top of the roller-coaster' view. These recent chapters have been like a roller coaster slowly cranking its way up a hill -- progress, building excitement, building nerves and tension. This chapter felt like the coaster starting to creak backward in the middle of climbing the hill. If it's NOT creeping backward, but instead hitting the top of the hill and giving us all a pause for 'oh shit, we're about to..." like you get when you look down at a steep drop on a carnival ride... Then I think you missed what I assume you were aiming for it to feel like for readers. And if you could could give Alden something, ANYTHING in his mindset or endless ruminations that shows he is capable of changing or imagining any good from a future as a knight at all, rather than spending the chapter doing your best to convince us he will never willingly take that leap and will never want to, that would help tremendously too. Sorry that this is such an essay! I know it's going to probably go down tough. I'm expecting some blowback from readers. ;)

Anthony Lutz

i ain't reading all that. im happy for you tho, or sorry that happened. I jest, i probably will read it, but you realise you ALMOST wrote as much for this comment as this entire chapter.. only 22 words short! but a preemptive comment since i likely won't comment on the minutiae of your essay, Sleyca knows where the story is headed, and also where it likely ends, we're just along for the ride as she makes a narrow way towards it. The story often feels off chapter by chapter, but re-reading it without the multi-day breaks reads a lot differently. It might be better to leave your summary here and link an online document for your bonus chapter there to avoid clogging the comments. i know mobile patreon defaults to a collapsed comment, but desktop doesn't have that, so your wall of text is quite intimidating.

Cécile Chevrier

J'ai aussi des gens autour de moi a qui j'adorerais faire lire ça. Quitte a rêver, autant demander une version imprimable du tout !

Heckate

I've been enjoying Alden's choosing season, there are a lot of little bits that are coming together to build a strong feeling of desperation and frustration. It doesn't all fit together smoothly but I expect it will probably feel better after this arc's climax (or perhaps it will be more obvious how it should fit together later - this is one of the issues with writing serials, alas)

Mack

Why doesn’t Alden just tell Stu’art that he’s avoiding the conversation about taking future skills because for reasons he does not want to discuss, Stu’art looking into it on his behalf is causing him stress. But that the reason is none of the things Stu thinks, and to please give him time before looking into skills more. Stu seems the type to respect that. And if he looked into it anyway then he can’t be frustrated when he finally comes to understand the reasoning much later.

Francis

I am predicting that Alden will get around the tattoo in one of the following ways: 1. When he visits Stu he talks to Mother and asks her to help (he would owe her then, which might involve him committing to Knighthood in the future, but let's not go there now) 2. When he visits Stu, the Primary is there unexpectedly. Alden tells him about the skill, because he just has to accept "endless misery on the horizon" then the conditions are fulfilled for him to tell the Primary. 3. One of Stu's parents sees Alden's reaction to Stu's questions and immediately realise that it must be a secrecy tattoo .

JJ Hunter

Speaking of fetal care and birthing centers, Alden still hasn't had his thank you chat with the birthing center in Nashville he donated to (175), has he. I feel like both that call and this pending interaction around the artificial womb repair needed offer an excellent opportunity for Alden to advocate for Porti-loth's birth trees for human Avowed planting project.

JJ Hunter

I will be fascinated to see how long it takes Alden to remember he has a [correction: volunteer] supervisor he can and should be contacting for advice if he feels like he's being asked to do something beyond his current comfort level. You're not the lone authority with a minor dependent on Moon Thegund anymore, Alden! You're working within a community, and you have competent advice available to you just a System-assisted thought away.

Terrestrial_Biped

It's hard to listen to "I'm not talking, and I won't discuss why" and not hear something negative like "I don't want to talk about it with *you*". Best case, Stu sees a very worrying decision to avoid thinking about something that *must* be considered in advance, which would be a huge danger sign in a young knight and will probably scare Stu silly.

Npf

I was wondering about the third option too. I also think that eventually (this is a solution for far in the future) Alden will have more authority than Joe and will be able to just break the contract himself. Another solution possibly even further in the future is that if Alden and Stu someday do the authority bond, then Stu can read some of his thoughts... But that also makes me really worried that Alden will realize that ahead of time and then not be able to authority bond with Stu because it would put the contract-enforced secrets at risk... (I'm really hoping that doesn't happen.)

Npf

The text conversation with Boe is so rough. I am so eager for Alden to tell Stuart he's a wizard, and Boe's description of the best/worst case scenarios were... bad. It actually did surprise me just how bad. It's rough that Boe saying "don't say anything for at least a decade" is such utterly reasonable advice. The argument was so genuinely persuasive. Maybe something will change the math later? Maybe Stu will affix and not do well and it will seem like the option of pursuing an authority bond might be the only way for him to live.

SpitEoll

I don't think an authority bond would happened to young people, it seems to be a very long process and I'm don't think it would happen to anyone unsteady in his path

J

Why can’t Alden just tell Stuart the name of his skill and have Stuart figure out the implied meanings from there? I’m pretty sure Mother was the one who told him the name and not Joe. And Stuart should be able to look up the skill considering it’s part of the first 300 avowed skills and find out that Alden has an infinite skill and doesn’t need another. Or am I misremembering and Joe did tell him the name? Edit: I looked back at chapter 39 and the wording for the secrecy contract is “will not, through any means or by any permutation of interpretation, intentionally reveal the information l'm about to disclose to you to anyone else of any species without my permission.” So revealing the name has the intention of revealing the information that his skill has no limit.

Anthony Lutz

Joe told him it was number 112 and that it was an original uncapped skill. Which means saying "Bearer of all Burdens" is the same as saying he has 112, and thus covered by secrecy.

Charles

Kibby needs to send Alden a message with the subject “musings on hesitation, the death it deals, and how to live a life that honors that sacrifice.”

Charles

Woah, I didn’t see the essay long comments made before I wrote this. Alden is portrayed fine (very believable). He has overcorrected from snap decision Alden of Chicago and all I am saying is he needs is some counter perspective.

Lyssur

I don't know- Alden doesn't really reach out to authority figures for help, which makes sense given his history. The one person he opened up to- slightly- was Big Snake about the drowning, and immediately regretted it. He's much more likely to reach out to his peers.

Eva

Have we is covered why this arc is called snow yet? Because I was just rereading and came across the chapter where mother shows Alden what happened in the snow with his sister Sina. And now I am feeling <> about where this is going

František Novák

Alden is about to start a cocaine smuggling business in Anesidora. He will use the last people Vandy would suspect - the book club - as his dealers. His new uncle will hide shipments in cars he sells to Anesidora. The public will title the mysterious criminal mind as... Snow baron.

František Novák

I just found out, BANANA tree is not a tree. It is a plant. It grows bananas once and then the main stem is cut off and new stem grows from the roots. Alden was lying about bananas coming from trees to the knights!

Baumlaus

As far as i know, it is closer related to grasses than trees. x) But i also feel like that is something a teenager might not know.

František Novák

You might have noticed the Contract´s hands off policy. They will not stop you or warn you when you are walking into a minefield. I think there is a big ass set of rules to not interfere with people (of all races) from it´s own initiative or motive. To the point of "I can totaly ET you, but you have the right to drown which takes precedence, until you ask for ET". Mother is working around that rule by answering Alden´s questions, leading the conversation to desired topics, and by adding the conversation to level ups, as that is her job.

nityaana

I wonder if sleyca is trying to align a Christmas/new year's chapter with the real time holiday? because this one feels too much like an aimless 1-2 chapter filler meant to accomplish that maybe sleyca doesn't want to lose focus from Alden's 'choosing season' until it reaches a satisfying end but this feels like a good point to add a different character pov? (someone who's not stuart) -one of the interesting but smaller side characters that we haven't seen in a while could be nice

Stuart Brown

Boe is wrong about the "worse case scenario". He doesn't have Alden's experience or insight into Artonan culture and politics. He's just a kid from Chicago. There is zero chance that the Artonans would wipe out a resource planet which can produce knights. There is too much reverence for people taking the path of highest onus. The knights are too valuable. There have already been knights from other species. They have less extreme options anyway-why wipe out a planet when you could isolate it instead? Or restrict Avowed further? Or why react at all, since Alden might simply be a unique outlier? Boe is acting like they are just Artonan shaped humans, and he's unduly cynical about humanity because of his unwanted power to read emotions.

František Novák

Flaws in your argument: - He is not a knight. He did not swear oath to serve. - If artonans ever wiped out another civilisation because of their wizards, they would definitely not make humans aware of it. - He is not a unique outlier. - Alden being a wizard puts Earth Contract into severe risk.

Anthony Lutz

There's 2 maybe 3 more chapters before real Christmas, with this mini quest probably having some focus, then the super hero snowball fight that hopefully Alden gets to experience, then "tomorrow". That's potentially a lot to pack into 2 chapters to hit a Christmas on Christmas chapter. Although sleyca could have been lying to us about writing delays just incase she could multi chapter drop Christmas to us, I think that unlikely.

JJ Hunter

Reasons for pursuing knighthood Alden hasn't yet considered, entry #24: if Alden successfully navigates the implicit class shifts involved (Avowed -> wizard -> hn'tyon), he might get an equal or greater voice on the committees deciding how his species should be managed as ambassadors like Bash-nor. ("I want you out of my Christmas market. Off my planet." -265)

PhoenixPax

It's funny and very characteristic that Alden has already spotted the downside to this but not consciously realized the upside. (He spiraled for a while about the possibility of being able to requisition avowed fighters and possibly having them die, and what that power would do to his social life.) Of course, he spotted the downside because Stu was musing about responsibilities he would have as a knight, but no one but Mother knows enough about Alden's situation to point out the upsides. Alden really has backed himself into a corner where no living person knows enough about his situation to be able to actually offer him on-point advice. Joe knows about only BoAB Boe knows about only Wizardry, he likely has no particular context for knights other than they exist Stu knows a lot about knights in general, but nothing about Alden being a candidate His therapist knows about neither Teachers know about neither (Edit: hit enter too soon)

JJ Hunter

Given Alden's running bit about tropical frogs Boe may or may not be missing, I feel it is important to inform you that a new frog dropped this week: https://www.sciencealert.com/new-species-of-tiny-pumpkin-toadlet-discovered-in-brazils-cloud-forests .

Casey

You know, there is no guarantee that if Alden joins the knights he and Stuart get to work together.

PhoenixPax

Stu's dad is the Primary. The Primary is worried Stu will die. Having a close friend as a squad-mate increases your odds of not getting terminally sad. Alden may not be any adult's ideal choice, but he's willing to stick by Stu, Stu wants to stick by him, and Stu would be frantic with worry if he gets shunted off to other Artonans that don't care about Alden. Also, keeping Alden safe so Stu doesn't get sad that he dies is best achieved by sticking him with someone he already has an emotional bond with. In other words, the odds that they are put together as a nearer to perfection pair are high. Based on what Stu said about Welcome End, people from the Rapports are looking for compatible squad-mates, which implies that personality fit and preference matter. But also, if there's a big problem, squads can be broken up to try to keep problems from spiraling. (Ryada being kept away from Welcome End activities once her skill regret became known and it seems like she was moved off her squad too.) In other words, we've been shown that squads are managed delicately, not mechanically or randomly, according to principles that authorities think will give every kid the best chance to grow up and get past the initial challenges of being a knight.

PhoenixPax

Oh my -- I'm slow on the uptake. I just reread Chapter 258 which is the call Stu has with Alden just after Stu talked to the Primary. They wrap up the call and then Stu goes to the manuscript library to start researching stuff for Alden. At the time, the two things didn't seem connected...

jg

I'm still worried about the story , this book 2 arc has the feel of Everests south col. The black mountain towers above and sleyca's exhausted. She has slipped down the Lhotse glacier once recently. Climb! Base camp is rooting for you! ( In the usaian not the Aussie sense btw ) ( For most of us anyway ) ( A joke, why was she called Wendy Wombat? Because she eats roots and leaves )

JJ Hunter

On reread, I'm kind of fascinated that Stu says Calassa Mom is "often the best person in the house to go to for stories about Iella", and the one most likely to be critical of how he manages himself in social situations; I would have guessed Rel was filling both of those niches. If anyone needs a refresh on Calassa's most recent appearance before this one, she was hanging out with Olorn when Stu contacted her for help with summoning Kon (232), and Calassa was the one collecting information about the wand's past. I wonder if Calassa might have been the one to make the call that that situation was within Stu, Bithe, Alden, and Kon's abilities to resolve, and the spousal crew shouldn't come in person to take over. ("'Excellent,' Calassa said. Then, she made a series of hand signs that Olorn caught with one eye.")

JJ Hunter

Stu is tempted to ask Calassa for help detangling why Alden has started acting oddly, but it also sounds like Calassa might be a really good person to help with fully identifying the nature and core concepts of Alden's skill. "Asking for her help with almost any school assignment was bound to be fascinating, but it would take thrice as long as talking to his other parents about the same thing and sometimes result in follow-up lessons days later." She sounds a bit like Ro-den if Ro actually enjoyed teaching.

Tacit Candor

I'm a bit concerned that Alden's internal dialogue described death as a release from stressors on three separate occasions this chapter (not always his own death, but still death). I can't remember if that's been a recurring thing besides right after affixing... but perhaps comparing his current mental state to post-affixation is enough of a red flag as it is. The imposition on autonomy being made by the triangle of absolute secrecy, and the way it contrasts with Artonans' elevated understanding of autonomy via wizardry/authority, has been bopping around in my mind the past day or two. I'm wondering if Alden's inability to act in everyday life due to this contract is echoing his inability to assert his authority post-affixation in ways that are more deleterious than he might yet realize.

PhoenixPax

Very interesting analysis! I would personally say this chapter is definitely way worse than post-affixation. Back then, Alden was handling the assorted stresses like a champ: he was pre-warned, he managed his own thoughts, and he knew if he got through it, he would eventually feel better and get his magic back. I can't remember him ever being shown straying to death-related thoughts, even as a humor 'coping' strategy.

JJ Hunter

Now that Bash has been effectively banished from his ambassador post with a little help from Alden, it's interesting to revisit Alden's prior encounter with him in 'Big Tippers' (174), and how Bash-nor's behavior directly contrasts with Ro-den's. Despite Alden lumping the two of them together as both 'big tippers', it's clear Alden is unsettled by Bash-nor and dislikes him, whereas Alden continues to have much more complicated feelings about 'Joe' / Ro-den.

FeathersFavoriteNYC

Hey, no one called for chapter predictions yet?

JJ Hunter

Alden was warned more than once that Bash-nor could be dangerous to him - first Esh taking proactive steps to prevent Bash-nor from trying to 'use' Alden, then Zeridee more explicitly warning Alden not to challenge Bash-nor's sense of superiority if he was unlucky enough to meet him. In person, Bash-nor quickly validates those warnings. "'If I slapped an enemy who was trying to kill a child instead of using my full strength…' He lifted a hand, flared his fingers in and out rapidly, and a sharp metallic-looking thing appeared hovering over his palm. It looked like a crown made of icepicks. It looked like a crown made of icepicks. Alden was pretty sure it was a spell effect generated partially by his rings, but he couldn’t swear it wasn’t a solid object. 'Would you still say I had fought bravely and done my best?' Alden’s eyes were fixed on the icepick crown. It disappeared suddenly and he blinked, refocusing on the ambassador’s face." (174) This "very lethal looking spell" (175) makes such an impression on Alden that the next time he encounters Bash-nor, he automatically checks the risk Bash-nor might do it again. ("Alden’s eyes went immediately to the hand Bash-nor had used to show off the threatening-looking spiked spell the last time they’d met, in the hallway outside Ro-den’s room at Matadero. But the ring the ambassador had used for that was missing" (262).)

Casey

I mean... as much as I would love for the next chapter to come out at midnight, sometime after midnight tomorrow is more likely. Okay, here is my chapter prediction: Alden realizes the only way to tell Stuart his secrets is if they became one person, legally speaking. They go get married and happily fight choas together there after.

Jeremy Goldberg

these chapters remind me of the waves chapters. It’s supposed to be Alden’s choosing season, but it feels like his choices and agency are getting stripped away from him little by little.

JJ Hunter

It does feel like Alden's getting snowed under little by little, doesn't it. I hope he doesn't end up in white out conditions...

JJ Hunter

On nth reread, that black husenot with the white stripe representing Stu's past difficulties and how he's been changed by them is squeezing my heart to an alarming degree (that's white stripe like a cleaving, a cut that connected him to a better place and to people who love him in a (mostly) healthier way). Interesting that Stu picked a red husenot instead of a blue one to represent his friendship with human Alden. The purple husenot for his future hopes and what he longs to be able to say to his father in the future is just so lovely. Having his better stones periodically pick themselves up and slowly battle for more ideal positioning near the pond is not necessarily what I would think of myself for how to establish the foundation of a tower, but I bet it will make for an interesting Rorschach's blot -type thought prompt over time.

Sean Shivers

Its cause the coat was red. I don't think he has any association of Alden & blue.

puppy0cam

Chapter Predictions!

puppy0cam

Better Alden breaks into the husenot room and eats a few of the husenots. She has to go to the vet b cause living rocks aren't good for dino-dragon health. Alden gets swarmed by a cult trying to not so subtley kidnap him as a sacrifice for the dark ritual™️. Mother intervenes in Alden's situation. I've got a somewhat half baked theory that she occasionally chooses to intervene when a knight's mental health start spiralling for utterly fixable reasons. This might count. Stuart slips on a banana peel because Alden needed to sabotage his skill/spell research. A lizard presses a button and a speaker plays a prerecorded sound of someone saying "lizard" Boe attempts to rescue some animals in need to pay off some of his self-inflicted heroism debt. It goes miserably. Incoming call from Hannah because Alden's life isn't complicated enough.

PatienceHoney

It's Monday! Sleyca said she would drop a chapter on Monday-ish and with my eternal optimism I was thinking the -ish meant that it could have dropped on Sunday night...

JJ Hunter

Circling back to the fundamentals of knight squad composition ("Usually, some people hunt demons, some repair the environment, and others facilitate the accomplishment of those two objectives in whatever way suits their abilities"), Jeneth-art'h is clearly in the demon-hunting category, whereas Alis-art'h appears to be peak environmental repair; did their lost third sibling-of-the-womb have a support skill of some kind?

JJ Hunter

I wonder if Kon will one day be able to effect environmental repair via sea-saying? Will his skill develop beyond the reading of record and reverting to record of individual objects to whole areas? Lexi seems firmly in the demon slashing, puncturing, and searing camp; Haoyu could fight or support at need. Lute is obviously support-coded; mass bestowal sounds designed for helping knights stack wordchains in environments where the usual wordchain effect is substantially weakened and many chains need to be piled on to get near the usual effect of one.

Andrew Simpson

I think Alden should totally take as much time as he thinks he should to tell stu about him being a kind-of-knight. I just think he should be less angsty about it in the meantime. Even this contract tattoo stuff seems to only be a problem now because he's manifesting a bunch of anxiety now that is twisting his intentions in a way thats triggering the tattoo when it didn't use to. I've also really enjoyed the focus on Alden's school life and the candidly more interesting SoL social interactions of him at school and figuring out what he wants from life in a more mundane way. Him finally getting to look around after escaping the shadow of his trauma is refreshing. It really does feel like all the artonan stuff is kind of just going in circles without much actually happening or changing. At this rate, I don't expect anything to really happen until Alden has to affix in a few months, or until stu affixes and he tells him (whichever comes first). Regardless, his secret comes out anyway when he has to affix because he'll be powerless and in a very specific kind of recovery for weeks/months, so all this ennui seems a bit pointless. There's an idiom I can never quite remember about borrowing trouble from the future as a metaphor for the futility of this kind of anxiety that seems appropriate here.

M

Probably not the idiom you're thinking of but I've always loved "There's no point in doing tomorrow's dishes"/"Stop doing tomorrow's dishes" as a way to tell people to stop stressing out about things that haven't happened yet

Sleyca

Do not stay up late tonight waiting for the chapter. Do message me if your sub is ending today/tomorrow and you'd like for me to send you the chapter.

jg

Just when I << specifically >> thought of your << approximately >> timeframe

Jeremy Goldberg

One side effect of Alden running into the limits of the Triangle of Absolute Secrecy might be that he’ll think way more carefully about his friendship contract with Stu and his upcoming Madero secrecy contract.

JJ Hunter

I miss Maricel. I hope Alden gets to see her again soon.

zetorian

I wonder how she's doing in the wake of all the political drama surrounding the submerged disaster. Being the 'model globie' in that whole mess can't be easy. There's also the bit where she turned down the family visit - assuming Fragment intended it for Maricel and not someone else. I hope there hasn't been a familial falling out as a result of the political drama on top of everything.

MWF

On my bucket list of things Alden does pre knighthood, one of them involves that overdue conversation with boe about what uniques are. That feels important. Also just knowing how the commendation works more clearly so he knows how that will help/hurt his knighthood. Also also because it might give him some more insight into Gorgon's powers.

Sean Shivers

There's a chapter called avalanch from a year ago and i saw it randomly and was very scared about what was about to happen.

J Reynolds

A year? Avalanche was posted to Royal Road on February 22, 2024! Time flies when you're having fun!

Benjamin Collins

Does anyone else think a possible path is that alden tells Stuart he's a knight and that makes Stuart want to go full magic so he can be aldens votory

John Koor

[Boe: Wait at least a decade before you make any decisions about the wizard thing.] [Alden: Yeah. I know.] Oof. So 50 years irl before a chapter happens where Alden finally tells Stu?